Sure, the Voters are going to give the award to Carpenter. They've proven that they look at wins as a determining factor before, and the fact is, Carpenter has more wins than Clemens, despite not pitching as well. You can come up with whatever weird arguments you want, (Carpenter not pitching in tight games, Carpenter pitching more innings etc...), but the fact is, Clemens has been a better pitcher this season. I don't see how anyone that isn't wearing incredibly bright red sunglasses couldn't see this. Now, does Clemens being the better pitcher mean he deserves to win the Cy Young? Yes. Does it mean that the voters will vote for him? No, look at previous years, it doesn't happen that way, but it should.