I think this would be a decent deal, fair enough for both teams. Here is your 25 man if that's the case: Rotation: Zambrano, Lilly, Dempster, Hill, Lieber Bullpen: Marmol, Wood, Howry, Eyre, Wuertz, Lahey, Ascanio Starters: Roberts, Lee, Soriano, Fukudome, Ramirez, Soto, Pie, Theriot Bench: Blanco, Ward, DeRosa, Cintron, Payton If Lieber/Dempster suck, you still have Marshall and Hart at AAA starting, not being the long guy wasting away in MLB. If you want another lefty in the pen, you can use Pigniatello instead of Ascanio. I think Neal Cotts is pretty much out of the picture. The bench is pretty weak, but you have a nice mix of lefties and righties and DeRosa could get 2 or 3 starts a week if Ramirez and/or Fukudome need a day off. Ward will likely get 1 start a week in place of DLee, and Payton will be in there vs. tough lefties only to give Pie a break. The thought of Cintron getting any meaningful PT is putrid, but whatever.