Donaldson has major league starter potential too, without a doubt. He might have issues with his swing but those sound readily-fixable and don't make him too much of a project. I heard he struggles calling a real good game, which really concerns me if he is a true catcher. Fixing a swing is harder then it seems, that can take a lot of time. And he does not throw very accurately, and has trouble with his foot work behind the plate. I over all hate his pick. If he sticks at catcher I think he has no chance with his lack of defensive skills, at another position maybe he could have a little big league potential, but what position??? Third? First? Snipped out the offensive portion of the scouting report: He threw out 38.7% of base runners. I think there's hope defensively for him. I am still not sold I think there were better players we could have picked. I dont like him as a catcher, maybe at first, but his foot work problems, and a decent arm, combined with the fact he does not call a very good game make me not like this pick.