The defense wasn't that good. Pie made a couple above average plays (one that Soriano and Jones certainly would have made, one I'm not so sure about). They also had two defensive problems in the 4th-a bobble that led to an error and then another bobble that led to an inability to get an easy double play. The net effect of Marquis's defense was about zero-and those are about the only plays he needed them, because most of the contact was pop ups and soft ground balls. I do agree with you that if he gives up baserunners like this, he will not pitch many shutouts-he still might pitch well, but a team will break through once or twice with runners on. I just wanted to address this comment, as the defense was not helping Marquis out all day. Hm, well I didn't see the game so I was going off of what was said, so I guess I was sticking with what I had read about Pie's day too much.