I want everyone on my team to have a good OBP, but it usually starts with the lead-off hitter because he's going to get the most chances to get on base. I don't want Soriano moved from the lead-off spot. this doesn't make any sense. you're taking a limited minor league sample size and comparing it to major league stats. Guzman can draw lots of walks in the minors. When he was given a shot (very, very limited sample size) in the majors, he drew 3 walks and had 76 ABs. Given his age, he looks like a AAAA player (DIE HARD!). Also, Soriano currently has a .352 OBP, so....right now. I think Theriot was sitting around 360 when he was leading off, as well. Seemed like you were clamoring for him to be on the team and leading off, but whatever. I guess it can't do any harm to have him in the system. That's a false dilemma. We don't have to have Jones or Guzman. I'd rather have Guzman as a 5th OF than Jones as a starter (currently), but I don't want Guzman any where near the everyday lineup. Most of the reason I'd want Guzman is because he costs less, it has nothing to do with talent (or lack thereof). I would rather trade Jones and hand the job over to Pie.