The defenseman is the one who starts the charge up the ice, as you put it. He needs to know where his forwards are going to be. Of course their roles are different. But I don't think it's a stretch at all to describe the relationship of all five players as having something to do with "chemistry." breakouts are largely set plays, it's something you practice everday, and it's usually a system created by the coaching staff. the "chemistry" between a dman and a forward is almost non-existent. there are set plays in the offensive zone, but it's mostly a free-flow between the forwards (because you can't predict how a defense will react when things actually start happening in the offensive zone, whereas if you watch enough tape, you can see how a defense protects against a breakout). brian campbell is an offensive dman, but he's still a dman. he's going to pinch more often than most, but that doesn't make him any less of a dman. it should also be noted that he's not going to be on the ice with toews and kane on every shift at even strength. bleh, tried to find shift charts for this year but they're not available. i hate that nhl.com took them off their website. Breakouts are often set plays, but much of the time they aren't and you have to adapt to where the puck is when you're trying to clear it. i think there's a difference in what we're thinking about here. when i'm thinking breakout, i think your team has clear control of the puck and has a chance to set themselves up. there is something to be said for a guy like campbell and his ability to move the puck up ice (he's clearly one of the best in the game at it, up there with a guy like visnovsky -- well pre 07-08 visnovsky at least -- or zubov at his abiltiy to get the puck up ice), but i'm not sure how much of that is chemistry vs. just being able to see the ice really well. generally (again, not always), forwards go up the ice in the same fashion every time and it's more the defenseman being able to read the play well rather than knowing his teammates. one thing campbell has benefited from is playing with very, very good offensive players (sabres with drury and briere and vanek and pominville and the sharks with thornton at the end of last year), so he knows where good offensive players are supposed to be. that's going to make a guy like kane or toews or havlat look even better if he can apply it. and i think the campbell move is an alright move...it's really good in the short term and it's okay in the long term. i guess some of it comes down to which direction the cap moves (and most people think it's coming down soon), but the 'hawks have a very solid defenseman for a while if nothing changes in his game.