Pretty simple IMO. The ND team that lost to MSU wasn't very good. The ND team that has played ever since (nearly beating USC then routing BYU, UT and Navy) would have a shot at beating any team in America. I agreed with Mandel's column. Notre Dame has been dominant in their last three games with the exception of about a quarter and a half of the UT game. They've scored 49, 42 and 42 the last three weeks. And yes, the BYU and Navy D's aren't great, but the UT defense was holding a very good bunch of SEC teams under 20 points consistently, and Notre Dame piled up 28 offensive points on them (plus the 2 Zibby TDs). Bottom line, is that Notre Dame these days is looking a lot like a sixth-ranked team, whereas these other teams, such as Oregon, OSU, UCLA, etc. have not been looking very good these days. I think Mandel made this point well by talking about how VT, Oregon, Bama, etc. have played lately. Oregon, UCLA and Alabama in particular have not been very good lately, and if you look for a moment past the one-game record differential, Notre Dame is completely outperforming those teams. The schedule argument can't really apply either, because while ND has dominated UT and Navy the last couple of weeks, Bama has been failing to get in the endzone on a pitiful Mississippi State team, Oregon has been having to orchestrate crazy comebacks to beat Washington State, UCLA had to come back on Stanford and then got blitzed by a Zona team that then turned around and got smoked by the Washington Fighting Willinghams. Schedule or no schedule, the Irish have looked as good over the last month as any team in America besides the undefeateds and a couple of other high-ranked teams (LSU for instance).