I think it's way too much to give up for Reddick and I like him a bunch. I think a Barney, Vogelbach, Marmol, Jackson, Villanueva, and one of Alcantara, Amaya, or Candelario is enough to get Reddick AND Anderson. I mean, you'd be sending them a very cost controlled starting MI who's league average offensively and as good as anyone in the league defensively. Vogelbach is a future top 100 guy, likely within a year, with bigtime upside. Marmol has solid value, at a cost reduction, especially if he's a set up guy. Brett and Villanueva are both borderline top 100 guys that seem relatively safe to have ML careers. 100 at bats in the majors isn't going to kill Brett's value. The last group has excellent potential as well. It's like trading 3 B prospects, and a B- with upside(Sickels grading scale guesses) plus a starting SS and a very solid pen arm. Personally, I think thats enough to get those guys. Especially with the injury issues on Anderson, who I doubt has the same value currently, as Harden did, when we dealt for him. That being said, I seriously doubt Beane would package those two together.