Its not like we haven't gone down these conversations a ton, but IF we did add both Darvish and Cespedes, even kept Aramis as well. We're not a playoff team in 2012. And it very likely would have seen us keep Marshall, because we would have wanted more sure things in the pen. Would Shark have even been given a true shot at the rotation? Because you would have had Dempster, Darvish, Volstad(Z deal happens anyway), possibly still Maholm, Wells, and Garza. You would have had Byrd as your 4th OFer(think DeJesus was going to be a Cub anyway) along with Reed, Baker, LaHair, and probably a vet backup C. In the end, it wasn't a playoff team, you'd have had a payroll of 140+, and you'd have entered the following(2012) offseason around 110 mill, needing a C, a SP or 2, some bullpen help, and some bench help. You wouldn't have had a protected pick in the draft this year and you wouldn't have the returns from the Marshall, Dempster, or Maholm deals. In my mind, unless you're able to afford taking our payroll up to, or above 160, you're not turning the roster I just gave, into a perennial playoff force. Look, it sucks we may head into 2014 with a lesser shot at making the playoffs than if we had gone the other route, but I'd gladly lay money those odds are reversed from 2015 forward, with the path they've chosen.