Eh, I'll disagree somewhat. I definitely wouldn't classify it as poor, thats for certain. Last year, the onky FA we signed to major league deals were DeJesus, Maholm, Wood, Soler, and Concepcion. DeJesus has been solid enough. Maholm was very solid and brought us back what could turn out to be an excellent return. Wood didn't pan out, but it really seemed he was forced down Theo's throat by Ricketts anyway. Soler looks the part right now and Concepcion was either a horrible mistake or we got unlucky with the mono thing.(likely both) This year, its too early to judge obviously. But you can go through each of them individually and understand why the move was made. I figure we'll get a very solid return on that 50 mill overall. But you are right, he's not picking up the 3 WAR for nothing types-Of course, when he did it a decade ago, it was basically him, Beane, maybe a couple of others and about 25 dumbasses he was competing against. Things have changed and other teams have gotten smarter and leveled the field somewhat. I still figure though, that when a new market inefficiency emerges, we'll be at the very top of teams that exploits it until the rest figure it out.