If Neifi were an RBI guy hitting 6th or 7th you could possibly make an argument that a high BA is more important than an OBP, on the basis that his role is to drive in the 3-4-5 hitters. However, Neifi bats 2nd too often, and his role should be to get on base in front of Lee, Ramirez, Nomar, Burnitz, etc. Thus, a higher OBP is better because it increases the RBI opportunities that our run producers have.