Go with Vlad. AL MVP, 9 All-Star games, 2500 hits, 450 HR, Lifetime 140 OPS+, 10 100+ RBI years. Admittedly, his 59.3 WAR is on the lower end of HOFers, but the dude could mash and was so much fun to watch. Throughout his career my gut always told me this guy was a HOFer, so I'm going with it. It came down to picking between him and Walker with my final vote. I went with Walker, even though it felt so, so wrong. I assume Walker's defensive prowess was the difference there. Their offensive metrics are real similar. For some reason whenever Walker or a Rockies players come up I think about how laughably ridiculous Helton's 2000 season was and yet he still came in fifth in MVP voting. Him coming in fifth with these numbers is like the ultimate indication of that era: .372/.463/.698/1.162, 163 OPS+, 8.8 WAR, 216 hits, 59 Doubles, 42 Homers, 147 RBI FIFTH.... http://www.baseball-reference.com/awards/awards_2000.shtml#NLmvp