Stan Musial is the most underrated living baseball player. Opinions? This is what got me thinking about that. According to his metrical HOF Monitor, which basically combines all the metrics about what a player did during his career, Bill James' all-time leading batsman are: 454 - Stan Musial 451 - Ty Cobb 423 - Hank Aaron 422 - Babe Ruth 372 - Willie Mays 354 - Ted Williams 353 - Barry Bonds 352 - Lou Gehrig 349 - Rogers Hornsby 316 - Alex Rodriguez Imagine if Stan the Man had played in New York or Boston??