Cedeno has a lot of physical talent, seems to have an improving approach at the plate, and his minor league numbers dwarf Theriot's. And he's younger. Theriot is a nice decent league minimum player who doesn't hurt the team too much, but it's not like he's a great player. Why is this so astounding? Have you watched Cedeno at the plate? He is clueless. How about in the field? Remember the double play up the middle he muffed and lost us a game 2 weeks ago? I never want the ball hit to him past the 5th inning. He may be one of the least intelligent players I have ever seen. That's certainly a fantastic example of cherry picking a play. Nobody's saying Cedeno should get all the playing time, but I'm dumbfounded by anyone who thinks it's a slam dunk. Advantages of Cedeno: Extra-base hits, range, throwing arm Advantages of Theriot: Walks/getting on base, success rate on balls hit in his zone I'd still like to see Cedeno at SS and Theriot at 2B on days when both of them play. Not necessarily because Cedeno is that much better of an option at short, but because the defensive weaknesses Theriot has are scaled down a lot at 2B, and the defensive weaknesses Cedeno has exist at either position, so the overall defense should be improved.