The argument for having your better hitters batting earlier is that you'd normally like your better hitters getting more plate appearances than a guy who can "move the runners over". I don't think there's any argument that when Soriano is hitting well, he's a better hitter than Theriot. But he's not the Cubs best hitter so why should he bat 1st and not Ramirez or Lee? That's a different argument, though. I'd be all in favor of moving Lee and Ramirez up. I'd much rather see Fukudome-Lee-Ramirez than Fukudome-Theriot-Lee-Ramirez. It's not different. If the argument for Soriano batting 1st is getting your best hitters more PA, then it's a flawed argument because he is not the team's best hitter and could conceivably be out of the top 5. And if you are putting a guy who makes lots of outs 1 then you are making it more difficult to get more PA for your actual best hitters, let alone more PA with runners on base. Qualified with "hitting well", I'd argue Soriano is at worst the third best hitter on the team. Coupled with the likelihood of something Piniella will actually do, I think there's a better chance Soriano gets moved up than Lee/Ramirez. EDIT: Granted, the likelihood of Soriano hitting well at this point, let alone consistently well enough to be sufficient high in the order, is minimal. Until then, I'd much rather see a lineup of Fukudome-Lee-Ramirez, bunting be damned.