Unfortunately for you and soccer, it was a good decision. Even if you don't convert, you're forcing MSU to go at least 55 yards or so to get in field goal range with only around 45 seconds left. If you do get it, all you have to do is take a couple of knees and you get the W. It was only a good decision in hindsight. It was an easy kick. You make it, kick it off and then make them get into the endzone to win. If you don't make the kick, they get the ball back at around their 30 yard line. I would've went for it no matter what.