More of Maddux in April doesn't necessarily give you a better chance to win those games. I think it would be tough to start out the season with the 5 man fully intact. If you did, Zambrano would start April 3 (opening day) and then not again until April 11, with only 4 games between those dates. That is 7 off days. You spend the greater part of March getting guys used to 4 days rest. I wouldn't want Zambrano getting more than 5 days rest (pitch on the 9th) at that point in the season. Rest is great, but regular work is also necessary. You have to skip at least one guy early, to keep guys on reasonable schedules. I hate all these off days, they will be much more valuable in June, July or August. I think I'd go: Zambrano, off, Prior, off, Maddux, Williams, Zambrano, off, Prior, Maddux Williams, Rusch (unless Wood is healthy or Hill is miraculously called up), Zambrano, Prior, Maddux, Williams, Rusch (unless Wood is healthy or Hill is miraculously called up), off, Zambrano, Prior, Maddux. So, to start the season Zambrano would get 5, 5, 5 and 4 days rest between starts. Prior would get 5, 4, 5, 5 days. That sounds like the best plan. I hate the offdays, and I'd rather go with a 4 than a 5 man rotation. The pitchers need the rest later in the year more than they do in April.