Let's give everyone an award! I'm completely biased toward Payton, so I would say he's the best. But I would say: Barry Sanders is the best RUNNER of all time. He did the most with his touches of the ball. Jim Brown is the most complete running back of all time. Power, speed, vision, agility, best combo. Walter Payton was a better football player than both. Probably did nothing the best, but was right up there in everything. Not the best runner, but in the top 3. Not the strongest, but for his size was as powerful as any. Not the fastest, but had breakaway ability. Not the most agile, but made people miss with the best of them. Plus, he's the best receiver, blocker, and passer of the top RBs. Only led the league in rushing 1 time, despite easily the best back for most of his years. Horrible offensive teams he played on. Emmitt does deserve mention for his longevity, but I fully believe that offensive line helped him more than any other player can claim. That doesn't take away that he was still a great back. Bo Jackson and Herschel Walker were the most talented players I have ever had the pleasure of seeing. There may never be another athlete like Bo. Period. Brown, Sanders, and Payton to me are on the top tier. 2nd tier is Emmitt, Marcus Allen, OJ, Sayers, Dickerson, Dorsett 3rd tier is guys like Campbell, Jackson, Walker, Bettis, Faulk, Riggins, etc. BTW, do you guys realize that Edge and Tiki will go over 10,000 yards this year? Edge has played like 5 years.