This race will go down to the wire. Would have been interesting to throw Liriano's name in there had he completed the season the way he was projected to about a month ago. I think the voting will go: Jeter, Ortiz, Dye, Ramirez, Thome Hafner is often overlooked in the league for some odd reason, and is on the only team not in the playoff race of the MVP contenders. I'd actually probably vote for Dye, because he's the biggest surprise to me. Jeter would probably be 2nd, followed by Manny, Hafner, and Ortiz.