Nope. Eyre's never been a closer, and I wasn't talking about last year. Look at Cpatterson's post, he knew what I was talking about. In 2003, batters hit .227 against Ryan with a .330 OBP. In 2004, batters hit .219 against Eyre with a .310 OBP. The differences, of course, were in their respective opponent's SLG and ERA. Ryan's was much lower than Eyre's, due most likely to his superior stuff along with some other factors. As for WHIP, Eyre's was 1.33 and Ryan's was 1.37. I'm not trying to say that Eyre is equal to Ryan, becaues I know Ryan is much better. I was just trying to say that, in his career, he has had 3 good years, 2 of which were stellar. The third, 2003, was not stellar. Eyre might not be the best comparison, but he was the first mediocre lefthander that came to mind. I'm sure I could find more. Try Steve Kline, Chuck McElroy and Mike Stanton. Ryan has 42 career saves (exactly 10 less than Howry) works out to about 1.1 mil per lifetime save. Good deal for BJ!