I have to disagree with you about Ortiz. Yes, he's had a great year. But ARod certainly is more valuable. While their offensive numbers are equally impressive, ARod plays defense (and a good one at that), while Ortiz DH's. This tips it to ARod imo. I put Clemens just behind Carpenter. Carpenter has 7 complete games. That's the primary factor that tipped it for me. He goes deeper into games. He's also been the leader of the Cards staff this year. And while W/L records should not mean much, there is at least something minimally to be said about the fact that his ratio of W/L is much better than Clemens. And I'm sticking with Lee over Pujols. He may have cooled off, but his yearly numbers still equal Pujols'. Ortiz is 5th in the AL in WS, behind ARod, Sheff, Manny and Brian Roberts. He's fourth in RC/G, behind Pronk, Giambi and ARod. Yeah but A-Rod is also first in the AL in being an egotistical, self-centered jackass. On a more serious note, the main argument I see supporting Ortiz getting the nod over A-Rod is Ortiz's "clutch hitting" this year. Their situational stats: With runners on:
AVG OBP SLG OPS
Ortiz .318 .427 .606 1.033
A-Rod .299 .402 .546 .948
With runners in scoring position:
AVG OBP SLG OPS
Ortiz .345 .455 .593 1.048
A-Rod .291 .414 .491 .905
Cy Young votes: AL: Santana NL: Carpenter (I would give it to Clemens, but he got one last year when he didn't deserve it so he loses it this year) NL MVP: Pujols