For every reason you can come up with for why he is still in San Diego, I can come up with one for why he shouldn't be. But, in the end, they are all just opinions, therefore it's not just "pure fantasy". Did the Cards make an offer? Seemed to me the Cardinals took the 2006 offseason off. If they did make an offer, were they the slightest bit serious? The Cardinals cried poor all offseason and picked up guys like Aaron Miles and Junior Spivey and Juan Encarnacion. And if the Cardinals offer was 8m and the Cubs offer was 12m, would Giles still not take the Cubs offer because he didn't accept the Cardinals offer? See, we can play this game all day. Hendry targeted Furcal. He expected to get Furcal. He basically ignored Giles from where I sit. The fact Giles is still in San Diego had more to do with the fact teams weren't showing the interest he was hoping for, IMO. If he couldn't get the offers he was hoping for, then I can't blame him for signing with San Diego again. It was very close to the arbitration date, and San Diego probably would not have offered it up, therefore Giles would not have been able to join San Diego until after May 1, making a switch to another team likely. Fact is, we really don't know either way.