Other guys to keep an eye on are Troy Percival and Brian Wilson. Only thing with Wilson is the Giants won't win many games. I picked up Lyon (Percival and Accardo both got drafted). Is C.J. Wilson or Brian Wilson a better option? Should I pick up either? I've got Blanton as a 6th starting pitcher after Peavy, Young, Hill, Pedro, Burnett in a 1250 IP max league. If I want to pick up a 3rd closer, I'd either have to drop Blanton or my only backup at 2nd or C, Orlando Hudson or Mike Napoli. If I had to pick between Brian and CJ, I'd probably pick CJ. As far as keeping a 3rd closer, I'd MUCH rather have a 3rd closer than a back up catcher. A lot of times, you can insert an extra closer in a "P" position and have all 3 collecting points, depending on the type of league you are competing in. Even in daily roster change leagues, it's almost impossible to know if your starting catcher will be having an off day other than maybe a team being scheduled off one day, but your back up's team could be off that day as well. And if your starting catcher gets hurt, you can usually find replacement catchers on the waiver wire. I rarely see teams keep a back up catcher unless there is a plethora of bench spots at your disposal, or unless they decided to hoard the best catchers for trade later.