I was all for selling high on DeRosa. I didn't think that would mean trading for marginal relief prospects and signing Aaron Freaking Miles. I think BBB's point was that selling high on DeRosa (something I was also in favor of) was fine to the extent you don't "aggrevate" the loss by signing someone who is injury-prone to play in a spot that DeRosa could fill. So, had we signed Adam Dunn, for example, losing DeRosa wouldn't mean as much as it does. The only solace - which I have not seen brought up but might have missed - is that Fukudome can always play RF if and when Bradley is hurt. Johnson would then play full-time in CF, or platoon with Pie (assuming he is still here). Not great, but not horrendous either, IMO. The first paragraph is pretty accurate. I don't mind signing Bradley if DeRosa is the guy who can step into that spot when Bradley is hurt. Now we don't have DeRosa and Bradley WILL be hurt. As far as the second paragraph, I think you are correct up to the point you mention Pie. I think Pie will be the next victim. IIRC, Pie is out of options. The Cubs signed Joey Gathright, so reword your paragraph with Gathright and Johnson splitting time in CF and I think that's the likely scenario. Regardless, I'm very disappointed in the return for DeRosa. I'd have much rather seen some sort of return that might have been included in a deal for Hermida, Hawpe, Choo, Scott, Kubel or some other LH bat that won't cost 10m to play half a season.