You are more confident in Wells, Gorz, Z, and Silva than I am. You, I, no one knows what we're going to get from Z for the remainder of his contract. Is Randy Wells a major league starter? Probably, but I would be surprised if he turns in an ERA+ over 100 this season or next. I just don't see him as an above average major league starter. Silva has been our best starter this season. We're all shocked. We're all just holding our breath hoping he doesn't get injured or crash and burn. I think he may be 'fixed' as a pitcher. However, he doesn't seem super durable. He has been awesome on the field this year, but can you depend on him to perform at the top of a rotation going into a season? Gorz......I'm not sure what we have with Gorzelanny. I think it's a stretch to have confidence in him turning in an ERA+ over 100 next year over 30 starts, but I definitely have him penciled into the rotation next year. Luckily, we have some more time to make these decisions. We can see how Gorz performs now that he's back in the rotation. We can see whether Wells has a resurgence. We will continue holding our breath with Silva...for now, we can only hope Z comes back stronger than he's been this year. If we do plan to get rid of Lilly, would we get a greater return via trade or via compensation pick? If we are wanting to have a rookie as an option for the rotation next next year, then shouldn't we part with Lilly sooner rather than later so that we could potentially get Cashner in the rotation for part of this season? By parting with Lilly, you're parting with consistency, a known commodity. If/Once we let him go, we're rolling dice on yet another rotation spot. Rolling those dice may very well be in the club's best interest if they are able to improve the offense, but the rotation will be worse for it.