Everyone had nice things to say about Trestman when he was hired, largely in the context of his days as an offensive coordinator and QB coach. Manning gets a bum rap, IMO. His worst seasons tend to correspond with horrific injuries to his best weapons / o-line and/or a terrible o-line to begin with. He's not Peyton, but he's not Jeff George either. EDIT: I'd take Manning's career over Phil Rivers', which was the other option at that time. Hating on Eli is the meatball thing to do in NY. Their defense is a mess, their o-line sucks, and they just switched o-coordinators after years of the very blah Kevin Gilbride.