Tim.... Heyward, Chatwood, and Montgomery for Cueto (out for 2019 TJS), Melancon, and Watson? Yes? Maybe? Chatwood & Melancon basically cancel out. Monty & Watson swap places with Watson giving us more of a pure pen lefty and SF more of a starter. Which leaves Heyward & Cueto. Cueto is guaranteed to provide no value next year and is no great bet at all when he returns from surgery at 34. Heyward's contract is longer, but the annual cost is similar and Cueto is somehow a worse bet than Heyward. I guess I'd do it. If SF could fix Chatwood, they'd win the deal. But it would also mean we'd need a CF next year unless people trust a Happ/Almora platoon. I was on the fence on it too, it's one of those odd deals that isn't one-sided currently but so many x-factors to delve into that future predicting is obscured by team needs. (SF needs an athletic OF in RF with gap to gap power, Cubs need BP help, SF needs a starter for '19 etc).