To refute this, I'm saying that a player's performance does not shift whether or not there is a base runner on or not. The fact that his numbers are different with runners on is all just a matter of coincidence. A player doesn't suddenly gain better offensive ability (or worse), based on the situation at hand, i just cannot believe that theory. Well, you're wrong. Pitchers pitch differently with RISP, and are likely to leave more balls over the plate. Therefore, there is a difference when hitting with runners on. Good hitters, like Ramirez, will make pitchers pay for challenging them. Agreed. Some hitters are more locked in at the plate in big situations too, and on the flip side some hitters get more jittery in big spots. Baseball players are human after all, and don't always go up to the plate with the same mindset. exactly. This is true in all sports. Some guys are clutch free throw shooters, some are not. Believe me, in the day, you would much, much rather have Billy Williams up in a big situation than Ron Santo. You can't compare "clutch" in basketball to "clutch" in baseball, they're two very different sports. People quote numbers they don't understand? They read a book, so they know all? Now that you mention "nonsensicle"...