Every year it's the same thing. The media ties them to a top teir free agent and then they end up signing whoever will sign for X dollars for X years. That's how they got Swanson. Going into that year's offseason, Dansby was the fourth SS by a large margin. He would have been hitting 8th or 9th in the batting order in Atlanta. They paid a price for Tucker and then teased at an extension, knowing full well it wouldn't happen unless a lot of other things happened first.
And every year we have the same conversations that go something like this: "I'm glad the Cubs didn't sign him to that contract." "He must have wanted to go to team X, because the Cubs offer was similar." "This guy they just signed kind of sucks, but it at least they didn't overpay." "I wouldn't sign player X to that fourth year either."
God forbid they pay one penny more or one year more than "good value".