I'm not sure how this doesn't exclude the Michigan-Ohio State game. Fans of both programs expect their team to compete for a national championship every year. A lot of Michigan fans want Lloyd Carr gone after this season. While it's true that he's had trouble beating Tressel, they also have struggled in bowl games recently, and haven't really contended for a national title since the mid '90s (unless you count last year). My pick was Army-Navy. Here are some reasons why... You also have the president attending the game, switching sides at halftime. Navy stamps "BEAT ARMY" on the weights in their locker room, and those words were also on the tile at the bottom of one of the natatorium's pools. The Army-Navy game is meaningful even if both teams come into the game winless; I don't think many people would care about Michigan-Ohio State if both teams completely sucked. I guess I just like all the tradition and the mutual respect in the Army-Navy rivalry, so that was my choice.