my thought process: Bert Blyleven - 146.3 WARP3. Not really dominant, and played on a lot of bad teams, but deserves credit for his longevity and durability. I voted yes. Dave Concepcion - great fielder, but couldn't hit, and unlike Ozzie Smith he didn't get on base much. Fairly underrated by the SABR community - he's better than some of the HoF SS - but he still shouldn't be in Andre Dawson - As much as I loved the Hawk, his career OBP of .323 is pretty terrible. Objectively, a 105.3 WARP3 in 2627 games doesn't come close to being enough for the Hall. Goose Gossage - I really have no idea. I couldn't differentiate much between him and Lee Smith, and chose to leave them both out, but I can see arguments for having them both in. Don Mattingly - excellent numbers early in his career, but injuries made him mediocre later. 84.7 WARP3 in 1750 games. Unfortunately he wasn't healthy enough to put up Hall-worthy numbers. Mark McGwire - voted yes... roids aside, he was a great player and his numbers are easily Hall-worthy. Dale Murphy - no. would've been nice to see what he could've done if his knees weren't so bad, though. Tim Raines - 123.9 WARP3 in 2500 games. I voted no - my standards are pretty high for corner outfielders - but I'm rethinking that. Actually after looking into it more, he's better than most of the LF in the Hall. He should be in. Jim Rice - overrated because he played during a fairly offensive era and played in a hitters' park. 83.2 WARP3 in about 2000 games - nothing special. Alan Trammell - as stated above, this should be a no-brainer.