Then you would be creating another hole on the team. Not if they're determined to pick up at least 2 other starting pitchers. It all hinges on what else Hendry can get done. And Sanchez seems pretty good. That deal doesnt make sense. You dont trade a staff ace. Their determined to pick up at least 2 other starting pitchers? Who are these guys that are better than Zambrano? Who said better than Zambrano? STL won after letting their past ace, Morris, leave. The Yankees went on an ace acquiring binge in the 2000s and didn't win the WS. Florida got rid of their best pitchers and are poised to be better than the Cubs for a while. Oakland has won despite ace type pitchers leaving. It's never good to get rid of a great pitcher. But it's all about the net gain. If you can turn that 1 great pitcher into 1 great position player and 2 good pitchers, you are probably better off. Who are the good pitchers? If you're talking about someone like Sanchez, he hasn't thrown a pitch in the majors yet. If you're talking about two free agents, then that's a whole lot of money being spent along with bringing in a $25 million player. Your argument for not needing an ace is terribly flawed. The Marlins got rid of their best pitchers and are poised to be better than the Cubs for a while? The Marlins had their best pitchers and won a World Series. Oakland has won despite those pitchers leaving? Oakland has won with them, too. The Yankees won with guys like Clemens, Pettitte, Cone and El Duque. Their pursuit of an ace hasn't been their problem - it's that they keep signing one-year wonders like Jaret Wright or Carl Pavano, or over-the-hill vets like Randy Johnson and Kevin Brown. Those guys aren't aces, they're wannabe aces and former aces. The Red Sox signed Curt Schilling to go along with Pedro Martinez and Derek Lowe in 2004. Result? Won the World Series. Lowe and Pedro left after that year, and Schilling has probably not recovered from the injury he pitched through during the playoffs in '04. The Red Sox haven't come close to achieving the same success that they had in '04. And Matt Morris? Come on. His ERA+ his last two years in St Louis was 89 and 104. The year before he left St. Louis, he was the second worst starter on their staff, not exactly an ace. And, this year without this "ace" the Cards won 15 fewer games during the regular season. Meanwhile, Zambrano's ERA+ has been over 130 for the past four years. Putting him and Zambrano together is just a horrendous comparison.