Miguel Amaya is a Huge, Hulking Unknown for 2026 Cubs

[Matthew Trueblood]

Image courtesy of © Kamil Krzaczynski-Imagn Images

Miguel Amaya played exceptionally well in 2025. He batted .281/.314/.500. He hit a huge early-season home run in a comeback win against the Dodgers at Wrigley Field, which held up as one of the year's great, dramatic Cubs moments. He cleaned up the exchange from his mitt to the throwing hand when throwing out runners, and significantly improved his pop time as a result. He looked like a budding star, and exactly what the Cubs needed him to be.

You already know the 'but' that comes after all that, though. Amaya got hurt on a throw in Cincinnati in May, suffering a significant oblique strain that took him out of action until mid-August. Upon his return, he immediately suffered a gruesome-looking (though, thankfully, moderate) ankle injury while trying to beat out an infield hit in Toronto. He only took 103 plate appearances in the majors all season. After a 2024 campaign that provided some hope for his durability, this year was a sad reversion to his broader career pattern: lots of promise, and an injury to thwart every would-be breakout.

Thankfully, Carson Kelly had an exceptional season, even if much of that value was packed into the same period during which Amaya was healthy and effective. Kelly batted .249/.333/.428 in a much more robust sample of 421 plate appearances. He got a de facto promotion from splitting time behind the plate to playing as regularly as your typical starter, and although that ate into his production as the season wore on, he stayed healthy and delivered what was needed. He was especially good defensively.

Jed Hoyer and his staff have plenty of holes to fill and weaknesses to address as they try to build the 2026 Cubs and get to a second consecutive postseason. Because Kelly was so good and Amaya is still under team control, catcher will not be a priority for the front office this winter. Kelly and Amaya are likely to be the team's go-to options as the season begins. As good as they were in 2025, though, running it back with them next year carries a huge amount of risk.

Even when healthy, Amaya has been a bit of a chameleon. He's talented and dedicated, but he's also a tinkerer—and his tools are volatile. Amaya was one of the first darlings of bat-tracking data for the Cubs, when that suite of data rolled out in 2024. As the first half of that season wore on, though, he lost bat speed, struggling to find ways to make consistent contact. He made a major swing and stance overhaul in the middle of that season, which yielded terrific results, but he came back in 2025 with yet another swing.

Season	Month	Bat Speed	Swing Tilt	Attack Angle	Attack Direction	Contact Point (in.)	Depth in Box (in.)	Dist. Off Plate (in.)
2023	July	73.5	26.7	12.4	-10.2	37.6	26.9	30.7
2023	August	74.0	29.0	10.2	-9.0	36.5	26.5	29.6
2023	September	73.5	27.7	8.0	-0.9	32.0	27.8	30.0
2024	April	72.9	32.0	9.3	-1.7	34.1	29.4	30.5
2024	May	72.4	29.8	9.6	-5.6	36.5	29.5	28.5
2024	June	71.8	31.4	9.1	-3.4	33.1	31.0	28.1
2024	July	73.5	34.0	8.4	-6.0	32.1	29.5	26.1
2024	August	73.8	32.0	7.0	-5.6	28.1	28.6	26.3
2024	September	73.1	31.1	5.7	-4.0	26.6	27.5	26.4
2025	April	72.1	34.6	11.7	-12.7	31.6	29.0	27.2
2025	May	72.4	35.5	10.0	-8.4	30.0	29.5	26.5

After getting more aggressive with his swing but letting the ball get deeper in the hitting zone before contact in the second half of 2024, Amaya gave up a little bit of those gains in swing speed to open 2025, as he reegineered his swing to be steeper and catch the ball farther in front of his body. He became more of a pull hitter and caught the ball with the bat working uphill more, which led to a much lower ground-ball rate and fed that surge in power marked neatly by the homer against the Dodgers.

Had he stayed healthy, this version of Amaya probably would have hit 20 home runs, even in the limited playing time he was getting. He was a true and dangerous slugger, after years of being more of a slashing, balanced hitter and putting too many balls on the ground to tap into the value of his bat speed. Now, though, the question is whether that version of him will stick around. Each time he gets hurt (and even when he gets extended playing time without getting hurt), Amaya makes major changes to his process at the plate. 

By sticking with their existing catching corps, the Cubs are accepting substantial risk of regression. Kelly is likely due for some, given his age and track record. Amaya is, unavoidably, an enigma. He just had great success during a stint to open the season, but unfortunately, that's not a guarantee that he can (or will) come back in 2026 doing the same things. Still, it's smarter to make that bet than to spend some of their resources on that position this winter, so Amaya will be one of the most important players to watch in spring training and early-season play in 2026—and that's ok.

View full article