Matthew Trueblood
North Side Editor-
Posts
2,546 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
Chicago Cubs Videos
Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors
2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings
Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis
2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources
2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Blogs
Events
Forums
Store
Gallery
Everything posted by Matthew Trueblood
-
Given their other needs and the market that developed around him, the Cubs were never going to re-sign catcher Carson Kelly this winter. All along, their goal was to buy low on a player with a similarly balanced skill set, but with fewer bona fides and less earning power. They found such a backstop by claiming Joey Bart off waivers from the crosstown White Sox Friday, days after the South Siders had designated him for assignment. Bart, who will turn 30 next month, was the second overall pick in the 2018 MLB Draft. He was taken by the Giants, and briefly, the organization dreamed on him becoming the heir to Buster Posey behind the plate. That never came to fruition. Bart struggled so mightily in parts of four seasons in the majors with San Francisco that he was shipped off unceremoniously to Pittsburgh in early 2024. There, he briefly found some traction. Bart hit .265/.337/.462 in 282 plate appearances with the Pirates that year, and he's kept his on-base percentage above water ever since. However, that was the only real bust of brilliance he's shown in his career. In a bigger role in 2025, he maintained a .355 OBP but couldn't hold onto his power gains. He has plus bat speed, but whiffs too much to make the most of it, and mishits the ball more than a true all-or-nothing slugger, to boot. Behind the plate, he's not a butcher, but nor is he a whiz. He's about average at controlling the running game and draws good reviews as a handler of pitching staffs, but he grades poorly as a pitch framer and didn't make good use of the ABS system in its first season. He bounced from the Pirates to the outskirts of Atlanta before finishing his season with the desperate White Sox; he was never going to stick around for long on the South Side. This might also not be a long stop for Bart. This pickup is reminiscent of when the Cubs made a cash deal to acquire Matt Thais from the Angels two years ago to the day. Thaiss, too, was a very limited bat-first catcher who made sense on a roster that lacked a legitimate starting option, but the team agreed to sign Kelly less than a month later. Thaiss signed a split deal but ended up leaving the Cubs organization before ever playing for them. Bart's chances of staying around are a bit better, because the team has more demands on its budget and fewer good alternatives this winter. They might be in a better position to let a veteran come to camp and take a part-time job early on, knowing that either Bart or Miguel Amaya could be easily jettisoned if needed once Owen Ayers is ready to debut. This acquisition won't stop the team's hunt for a replacement for Kelly, but they can't afford to allocate many resources to the position, and they believe in Ayers enough to go into the coming season with a thinner catching corps than they usually would. Bart might be another quickly forgotten transient pitckup, or he might get 250 plate appearances for the 2027 Cubs. The team claimed him while he was in DFA limbo, but they've enfolded him into a new kind of limbo, for the time being. Image courtesy of David Butler II-Imagn Images View full article
-
Given their other needs and the market that developed around him, the Cubs were never going to re-sign catcher Carson Kelly this winter. All along, their goal was to buy low on a player with a similarly balanced skill set, but with fewer bona fides and less earning power. They found such a backstop by claiming Joey Bart off waivers from the crosstown White Sox Friday, days after the South Siders had designated him for assignment. Bart, who will turn 30 next month, was the second overall pick in the 2018 MLB Draft. He was taken by the Giants, and briefly, the organization dreamed on him becoming the heir to Buster Posey behind the plate. That never came to fruition. Bart struggled so mightily in parts of four seasons in the majors with San Francisco that he was shipped off unceremoniously to Pittsburgh in early 2024. There, he briefly found some traction. Bart hit .265/.337/.462 in 282 plate appearances with the Pirates that year, and he's kept his on-base percentage above water ever since. However, that was the only real bust of brilliance he's shown in his career. In a bigger role in 2025, he maintained a .355 OBP but couldn't hold onto his power gains. He has plus bat speed, but whiffs too much to make the most of it, and mishits the ball more than a true all-or-nothing slugger, to boot. Behind the plate, he's not a butcher, but nor is he a whiz. He's about average at controlling the running game and draws good reviews as a handler of pitching staffs, but he grades poorly as a pitch framer and didn't make good use of the ABS system in its first season. He bounced from the Pirates to the outskirts of Atlanta before finishing his season with the desperate White Sox; he was never going to stick around for long on the South Side. This might also not be a long stop for Bart. This pickup is reminiscent of when the Cubs made a cash deal to acquire Matt Thais from the Angels two years ago to the day. Thaiss, too, was a very limited bat-first catcher who made sense on a roster that lacked a legitimate starting option, but the team agreed to sign Kelly less than a month later. Thaiss signed a split deal but ended up leaving the Cubs organization before ever playing for them. Bart's chances of staying around are a bit better, because the team has more demands on its budget and fewer good alternatives this winter. They might be in a better position to let a veteran come to camp and take a part-time job early on, knowing that either Bart or Miguel Amaya could be easily jettisoned if needed once Owen Ayers is ready to debut. This acquisition won't stop the team's hunt for a replacement for Kelly, but they can't afford to allocate many resources to the position, and they believe in Ayers enough to go into the coming season with a thinner catching corps than they usually would. Bart might be another quickly forgotten transient pitckup, or he might get 250 plate appearances for the 2027 Cubs. The team claimed him while he was in DFA limbo, but they've enfolded him into a new kind of limbo, for the time being.
-
It's hard to project Justin Steele's 2027 season with much confidence. The signs all point in unfortunate directions. From about the middle of 2022 through the end of 2024, he was one of the best left-handed starting pitchers in baseball, but there were indications of trouble on the horizon even then. He was shut down for the final month of 2022 with a balky back. He lost time in the middle of 2023 with an elbow issue, then had a hamstring strain early and more elbow trouble late in 2024. When he blew out his already-repaired ulnar collateral ligament and had to undergo a second reconstruction thereof in early 2025, it wasn't much of a surprise. Steele also lost velocity over time, even before going under the knife. He averaged 92.2 miles per hour with his fastball in 2022 and touched 94 about 4% of the time. In 2023, he dipped to 91.8 MPH on average and touched 94 about one-third less often. In 2024, he sat at 91.5 and touched 94 just 1.6% of the time, and in limited action before needing surgery in 2025, he was on the wrong side of 91 MPH, with no extra juice in the tank. Last offseason, all the updates from Steele and the Cubs were encouraging. There was great hope that he would not only return stronger than ever, but do so on a shorter timeline than had first been projected. The plan was a debut around July 1, but Steele started to target Memorial Day, instead, and the team was on board. Then, that plan exploded. One spring setback scrubbed any hopes of the early return. A second one after the start of the season made clear that he could only chip in as a late-season addition, perhaps in the bullpen. Ultimately, he didn't even get back onto a big-league mound, and he threw only 90.5 MPH with his fastball during his short rehab appearances with the Iowa Cubs in September. Desperate for Starting Arms, Cubs Likely to Re-Sign Justin Steele Yet, Steele is likely to re-up with the Cubs Friday. Rather than risk any form of the arbitration process, the two sides will probably strike an agreement that locks in Steele's salary for 2027 somewhere near the $6.8 million he made in 2026. It's not at all clear that Steele can be an average (let alone front-line) starting pitcher next year, but the Cubs have yet to add a starting candidate since the end of the season, and they've made clear that their faith in Javier Assad, Edward Cabrera and Braxton Garrett is limited. They can't afford to jettison Steele, even though they also can't afford to count on him. For that very reason, a few other players might get shoved off the roster Friday, even though their projected production matches their expected salaries better than Steele's matches his. Chicago has 37 players on its 40-man roster, including eight out-of-options relief pitchers. Over the first three weeks of this month, they've claimed two of those eight guys, in Eric Orze (from the Twins) and Chayce McDermott (from the Mets). They'll probably hold onto each of them, because right now is a hard time to sneak a player through waivers. Of the others, though, three arms stand out as more likely to be dumped—not to save money, primarily, but to create the space they'll need for a slew of additions (and, eventually, for in-season roster churn). Cubs Relievers Who Might Be Non-Tendered Ethan Roberts has had many, many chances to prove that he can stay healthy and/or be effective in middle relief. The Cubs selected him in the fourth round in 2018, and he debuted in 2022. In 63 games since then, though, he has a 4.70 career ERA in the majors. He's fanned fewer than 20% of opposing batters and walked more than 10% of them. He's arbitration-eligible, at last, but is projected to make little more than the league minimum next year. The real cost of keeping him is the way he clogs the 40-man roster, especially because he's now out of options. If Roberts can't ride the shuttle between Chicago and Des Moines, he has no value to the organization. They should move on. Virtually all of that is also true of Gavin Hollowell. The big righty was an intriguing waiver claim in late 2024, thanks to big velocity and a very funky delivery. Unfortunately, the funk is too much even for him. Hollowell has walked more than one of every eight batters he's faced in the bigs. The velocity bump that got the Cubs interested in the first place has ebbed away, too. He's physically fascinating on the mound, but he's a very boring version of bad on the stat sheet. He's out of options now, too, and cutting bait is the obvious move. The third cut from this group would be Tyler Ferguson, but truth be told, he has a better chance to stay in the mix. Ferguson's velocity is better than Hollowell's. His command is better than Roberts's. Though he got stung by the long ball this season, he also flashed the ability to miss bats and fill up the zone. He's older than Roberts or Hollowell, but his ceiling is much higher. The Cubs might eventually need his roster spot, but he should be able to hold it through Friday. Being out of options is the big strike against him, and he's good enough to bring to camp to compete for a job with the likes of Orze and McDermott. Goodbye, Gabriel Arias? One player who barely felt like part of the 2026 Cubs has managed to stick to their roster so far. Gabriel Arias was a waiver claim from the Mets way back in August, but even with Dansby Swanson injured for a while and Alex Bregman missing time at the end of the year, Arias only got into seven games and collected 10 plate appearances for the team. He looked like a natural candidate for a quick release after the season, or (failing that) to be non-tendered. He, too, is out of options and can't be freely sent to the minor leagues. However, the Cubs are short infield depth. They traded Jefferson Rojas to the Mets at the deadline. They have Matt Shaw and Pedro Ramírez right now, but one of the two could end up being an everyday outfielder for them in 2027, and the other might be traded for pitching help. James Triantos is currently projected to be on the team's Opening Day roster, even though Arias is, too. Other than Triantos (if he counts), the best infield prospect in the system is Jose Escobar, who has only played 78 games above Low-A; spent some time in the outfield last season; and went unprotected by the team at Tuesday's deadline to shield players from the Rule 5 Draft by adding them to the 40-man roster. The cupboard is bare. Arias is only projected to make around $1.3 million in 2027. His would be a low-friction roster spot to open, but at the moment, it's hard to confidently say that the Cubs can do better when it comes to backup infielders for next year. He might survive, too. How Cubs Might Get Active Quickly There are just a few interesting cases among the team's arb-eligible players, and as we've just seen, even those are fairly low-stakes questions. If the Cubs have an interesting Friday, it's likely to be because of whom they acquire, not because of whom they release or retain. Jarren Duran, a prominent non-tender candidate with the Red Sox, is on their radar. So is Twins left fielder Trevor Larnach, whose offseason wrist surgery complicates things but who had a strong season at the plate in 2026. Pitchers with both Boston (Tanner Houck, Kutter Crawford, Johan Oviedo) and Minnesota (Joe Ryan, Bailey Ober) are also in play. This winter, the team from the highway exchange northwest of Atlanta, the White Sox, the Tigers, the Twins and the Yankees have added free-agent pitchers at eight-figure annual salaries. The Rockies and Royals have made major pitching acquisitions via trade. Dustin May, Sonny Gray, Evan Phillips, Bryce Miller and Jose A. Ferrer were all appealing targets for the Cubs, but they all have their new homes already. Chicago needs to get down to business. They're not moving quickly enough to demonstrate the urgency they should feel to change their roster. On Friday, that could finally begin to change.
-
- ethan roberts
- gavin hollowell
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
It's hard to project Justin Steele's 2027 season with much confidence. The signs all point in unfortunate directions. From about the middle of 2022 through the end of 2024, he was one of the best left-handed starting pitchers in baseball, but there were indications of trouble on the horizon even then. He was shut down for the final month of 2022 with a balky back. He lost time in the middle of 2023 with an elbow issue, then had a hamstring strain early and more elbow trouble late in 2024. When he blew out his already-repaired ulnar collateral ligament and had to undergo a second reconstruction thereof in early 2025, it wasn't much of a surprise. Steele also lost velocity over time, even before going under the knife. He averaged 92.2 miles per hour with his fastball in 2022 and touched 94 about 4% of the time. In 2023, he dipped to 91.8 MPH on average and touched 94 about one-third less often. In 2024, he sat at 91.5 and touched 94 just 1.6% of the time, and in limited action before needing surgery in 2025, he was on the wrong side of 91 MPH, with no extra juice in the tank. Last offseason, all the updates from Steele and the Cubs were encouraging. There was great hope that he would not only return stronger than ever, but do so on a shorter timeline than had first been projected. The plan was a debut around July 1, but Steele started to target Memorial Day, instead, and the team was on board. Then, that plan exploded. One spring setback scrubbed any hopes of the early return. A second one after the start of the season made clear that he could only chip in as a late-season addition, perhaps in the bullpen. Ultimately, he didn't even get back onto a big-league mound, and he threw only 90.5 MPH with his fastball during his short rehab appearances with the Iowa Cubs in September. Desperate for Starting Arms, Cubs Likely to Re-Sign Justin Steele Yet, Steele is likely to re-up with the Cubs Friday. Rather than risk any form of the arbitration process, the two sides will probably strike an agreement that locks in Steele's salary for 2027 somewhere near the $6.8 million he made in 2026. It's not at all clear that Steele can be an average (let alone front-line) starting pitcher next year, but the Cubs have yet to add a starting candidate since the end of the season, and they've made clear that their faith in Javier Assad, Edward Cabrera and Braxton Garrett is limited. They can't afford to jettison Steele, even though they also can't afford to count on him. For that very reason, a few other players might get shoved off the roster Friday, even though their projected production matches their expected salaries better than Steele's matches his. Chicago has 37 players on its 40-man roster, including eight out-of-options relief pitchers. Over the first three weeks of this month, they've claimed two of those eight guys, in Eric Orze (from the Twins) and Chayce McDermott (from the Mets). They'll probably hold onto each of them, because right now is a hard time to sneak a player through waivers. Of the others, though, three arms stand out as more likely to be dumped—not to save money, primarily, but to create the space they'll need for a slew of additions (and, eventually, for in-season roster churn). Cubs Relievers Who Might Be Non-Tendered Ethan Roberts has had many, many chances to prove that he can stay healthy and/or be effective in middle relief. The Cubs selected him in the fourth round in 2018, and he debuted in 2022. In 63 games since then, though, he has a 4.70 career ERA in the majors. He's fanned fewer than 20% of opposing batters and walked more than 10% of them. He's arbitration-eligible, at last, but is projected to make little more than the league minimum next year. The real cost of keeping him is the way he clogs the 40-man roster, especially because he's now out of options. If Roberts can't ride the shuttle between Chicago and Des Moines, he has no value to the organization. They should move on. Virtually all of that is also true of Gavin Hollowell. The big righty was an intriguing waiver claim in late 2024, thanks to big velocity and a very funky delivery. Unfortunately, the funk is too much even for him. Hollowell has walked more than one of every eight batters he's faced in the bigs. The velocity bump that got the Cubs interested in the first place has ebbed away, too. He's physically fascinating on the mound, but he's a very boring version of bad on the stat sheet. He's out of options now, too, and cutting bait is the obvious move. The third cut from this group would be Tyler Ferguson, but truth be told, he has a better chance to stay in the mix. Ferguson's velocity is better than Hollowell's. His command is better than Roberts's. Though he got stung by the long ball this season, he also flashed the ability to miss bats and fill up the zone. He's older than Roberts or Hollowell, but his ceiling is much higher. The Cubs might eventually need his roster spot, but he should be able to hold it through Friday. Being out of options is the big strike against him, and he's good enough to bring to camp to compete for a job with the likes of Orze and McDermott. Goodbye, Gabriel Arias? One player who barely felt like part of the 2026 Cubs has managed to stick to their roster so far. Gabriel Arias was a waiver claim from the Mets way back in August, but even with Dansby Swanson injured for a while and Alex Bregman missing time at the end of the year, Arias only got into seven games and collected 10 plate appearances for the team. He looked like a natural candidate for a quick release after the season, or (failing that) to be non-tendered. He, too, is out of options and can't be freely sent to the minor leagues. However, the Cubs are short infield depth. They traded Jefferson Rojas to the Mets at the deadline. They have Matt Shaw and Pedro Ramírez right now, but one of the two could end up being an everyday outfielder for them in 2027, and the other might be traded for pitching help. James Triantos is currently projected to be on the team's Opening Day roster, even though Arias is, too. Other than Triantos (if he counts), the best infield prospect in the system is Jose Escobar, who has only played 78 games above Low-A; spent some time in the outfield last season; and went unprotected by the team at Tuesday's deadline to shield players from the Rule 5 Draft by adding them to the 40-man roster. The cupboard is bare. Arias is only projected to make around $1.3 million in 2027. His would be a low-friction roster spot to open, but at the moment, it's hard to confidently say that the Cubs can do better when it comes to backup infielders for next year. He might survive, too. How Cubs Might Get Active Quickly There are just a few interesting cases among the team's arb-eligible players, and as we've just seen, even those are fairly low-stakes questions. If the Cubs have an interesting Friday, it's likely to be because of whom they acquire, not because of whom they release or retain. Jarren Duran, a prominent non-tender candidate with the Red Sox, is on their radar. So is Twins left fielder Trevor Larnach, whose offseason wrist surgery complicates things but who had a strong season at the plate in 2026. Pitchers with both Boston (Tanner Houck, Kutter Crawford, Johan Oviedo) and Minnesota (Joe Ryan, Bailey Ober) are also in play. This winter, the team from the highway exchange northwest of Atlanta, the White Sox, the Tigers, the Twins and the Yankees have added free-agent pitchers at eight-figure annual salaries. The Rockies and Royals have made major pitching acquisitions via trade. Dustin May, Sonny Gray, Evan Phillips, Bryce Miller and Jose A. Ferrer were all appealing targets for the Cubs, but they all have their new homes already. Chicago needs to get down to business. They're not moving quickly enough to demonstrate the urgency they should feel to change their roster. On Friday, that could finally begin to change. Image courtesy of Michael McLoone-Imagn Images View full article
-
- ethan roberts
- gavin hollowell
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Is Jarren Duran the Right Kind of Problem for Cubs to Try to Solve?
Matthew Trueblood posted an article in Cubs
If nothing else changes the math first, the Boston Red Sox are likely to non-tender Jarren Duran at Firday's deadline to offer contracts to arbitration-eligible players. Duran, 30, is projected to earn $11.1 million this year, according to MLB Trade Rumors. That's a hard salary to justify, because he batted .207/.266/.361 in 2026. If tendered, he would be under team control for 2028, too, but his earning power currently seems out of line with his production. Nonetheless, the Chicago Cubs have interest in Duran, a source confirmed Thursday. Patrick Mooney of The Athletic reported the same news earlier in the day, along with a note that the team is in on posted Japanese outfielder Teruaki Sato. There's no question which of those two risky additions is preferable. Sato is younger, has more power upside and has demonstrated a more polished feel for hitting. However, Sato will also cost somewhere around $100 million over five years, and the Cubs are far from alone in having interest in him. They need a backup plan (or three), and Duran might prove to be a much more attainable, considerably lower-cost acquisition. That he's set to make an eight-figure salary in his third trip through arbitration speaks to the upside that Duran, too, possesses. In 2024, he was one of the best players in the sport. A very fast runner with a strong arm and good raw power, he put all his tools together at age 27 and became an All-Star. There was nothing subtle about the way he did it, either. Duran batted .285/.342/.492. He led the majors in both doubles (48) and triples (14) and swatted 21 home runs. He stole 34 bases in 41 tries, and he played above-average outfield defense. He was one of the game's most dynamic, well-rounded players. Even within that campaign, though, there were signs of trouble. In mid-August, Duran used a homophobic slur in response to a heckler. He apologized, but bad feelings have lingered between him and fans ever since, and he's done little to materially mend relationships with the LGBTQ+ community—or anyone else affronted by his behavior. In April 2026, he gave the middle finger to a fan who heckled him at Target Field in Minnesota. The fan, it was later revealed, had told Duran to kill himself—an unacceptable transgression made worse by the fact that Duran had disclosed a 2022 suicide attempt in a documentary about the 2025 Red Sox season. Duran's courage in being open about his struggles is commendable, but hardly anything else about his attitude or approach to the game during his Red Sox tenure has been so. Boston media members lament his lack of accountability and his combativeness. The erraticism that has characterized Duran's relationship with the community around his team has leaked into his game, too. After a 2025 season that was solid but less spectacular, he went off the rails altogether in 2026. He started expanding his zone more, even as the rules made the zone smaller and encouraged every hitter to swing less. He grew pull-happy, seemingly trying to hit for more power but actually producing less. Duran has plus-plus bat speed, but it was tragically misapplied in 2026. So was his foot speed, on defense, as his reads and routes on fly balls got noticeably worse, too. But for a series of injuries to Red Sox outfielders, he probably would have lost his job. Instead, he still managed 20 home runs and 21 stolen bases in (essentially) everyday playing time, but his rate stats cratered. There's no getting around it: Duran is a risk. He's a player in desperate need of a change of scenery, but there's no guarantee that such a change will put him back in touch with his talent. The Cubs could get him from Boston for virtually nothing, but only if they're willing to pay a handsome salary to roll the dice on those loud tools and risk wrecking a clubhouse culture in which the organization takes fierce pride. Somewhere and sometime this winter, though, the Cubs will have to take a big risk. They can do it by spending $100 million on Sato, or on Kaima Taira and his unique pitching frame. They can do it by paying Trevor Rogers like a near-ace, even though he's only pieced together two partial seasons of being such a hurler over a relatively long career. Another option is to bet on Duran's obvious talent and immense potential, and to hope the team's culture influences him, instead of things working the opposite way. Duran was effusive in his praise of Alex Bregman as a teammate and mentor, even after Bregman left the Red Sox to sign with the Cubs last winter. It might well be that a reunion with Bregman could help the outfielder get his groove back—not only in terms of being more focused and disciplined in his behavior, but in the at-bats he takes and the resulting production on the field. Pete Crow-Armstrong clearly benefited from Bregman's presence on the Cubs in 2026. That was visible, but it was also something Crow-Armstrong spoke to directly. Duran's approach at the plate turned his season far more sour than any of his off-field frustrations could. Bregman is the kind of teammate who helps other players improve on that score, and there's already evidence that he and Duran can work well together. The Cubs have a shoddy history of taking into consideration their fans from the LGBTQ+ community. They traded for Daniel Murphy in 2018, and treated objections to that move with unfortunate dismissiveness. Far too often, they have used owner Laura Ricketts (who is gay) as a shield against accusations of insensitivity to questions of inclusiveness, and her approval was used as a deflection for criticism of the trade. The team sends mixed signals to its fans about how welcome and included women, people of color and LGBTQ+ folks should feel. Bringing in Duran would risk exacerbating that state of affairs. However, room should also be made for second chances, and teams can't apply tests of worldview or perfect behavior to every possible transaction. If they did, many, many of the game's stars would have to be ruled out. If they bring in Duran, they need to have a better plan for the process of introducing him to their fans, including preparing him for questions about his 2024 transgression. They should ensure that he harbors genuine remorse for those actions, which was never in evidence with Murphy. They also need to be sure that they can help him become more effective and more positive in his relationships. That's a lot to hope for, for a player who might need to be picked up in an under-the-wire trade or snatched quickly from the free-agent scrap heap. It might all be more trouble than it's worth. There's a strong argument for spending the extra millions on Sato, if they can manage it. However, few players available this offseason have the impact potential of Duran. If the team's background work (via Bregman; via the organization's familiarity with Red Sox president of baseball operations Craig Breslow; or via whatever other channels are available) tells them he has a good chance of realizing that upside based on his on- and off-field approaches, they're right to seriously consider the gamble. -
If nothing else changes the math first, the Boston Red Sox are likely to non-tender Jarren Duran at Firday's deadline to offer contracts to arbitration-eligible players. Duran, 30, is projected to earn $11.1 million this year, according to MLB Trade Rumors. That's a hard salary to justify, because he batted .207/.266/.361 in 2026. If tendered, he would be under team control for 2028, too, but his earning power currently seems out of line with his production. Nonetheless, the Chicago Cubs have interest in Duran, a source confirmed Thursday. Patrick Mooney of The Athletic reported the same news earlier in the day, along with a note that the team is in on posted Japanese outfielder Teruaki Sato. There's no question which of those two risky additions is preferable. Sato is younger, has more power upside and has demonstrated a more polished feel for hitting. However, Sato will also cost somewhere around $100 million over five years, and the Cubs are far from alone in having interest in him. They need a backup plan (or three), and Duran might prove to be a much more attainable, considerably lower-cost acquisition. That he's set to make an eight-figure salary in his third trip through arbitration speaks to the upside that Duran, too, possesses. In 2024, he was one of the best players in the sport. A very fast runner with a strong arm and good raw power, he put all his tools together at age 27 and became an All-Star. There was nothing subtle about the way he did it, either. Duran batted .285/.342/.492. He led the majors in both doubles (48) and triples (14) and swatted 21 home runs. He stole 34 bases in 41 tries, and he played above-average outfield defense. He was one of the game's most dynamic, well-rounded players. Even within that campaign, though, there were signs of trouble. In mid-August, Duran used a homophobic slur in response to a heckler. He apologized, but bad feelings have lingered between him and fans ever since, and he's done little to materially mend relationships with the LGBTQ+ community—or anyone else affronted by his behavior. In April 2026, he gave the middle finger to a fan who heckled him at Target Field in Minnesota. The fan, it was later revealed, had told Duran to kill himself—an unacceptable transgression made worse by the fact that Duran had disclosed a 2022 suicide attempt in a documentary about the 2025 Red Sox season. Duran's courage in being open about his struggles is commendable, but hardly anything else about his attitude or approach to the game during his Red Sox tenure has been so. Boston media members lament his lack of accountability and his combativeness. The erraticism that has characterized Duran's relationship with the community around his team has leaked into his game, too. After a 2025 season that was solid but less spectacular, he went off the rails altogether in 2026. He started expanding his zone more, even as the rules made the zone smaller and encouraged every hitter to swing less. He grew pull-happy, seemingly trying to hit for more power but actually producing less. Duran has plus-plus bat speed, but it was tragically misapplied in 2026. So was his foot speed, on defense, as his reads and routes on fly balls got noticeably worse, too. But for a series of injuries to Red Sox outfielders, he probably would have lost his job. Instead, he still managed 20 home runs and 21 stolen bases in (essentially) everyday playing time, but his rate stats cratered. There's no getting around it: Duran is a risk. He's a player in desperate need of a change of scenery, but there's no guarantee that such a change will put him back in touch with his talent. The Cubs could get him from Boston for virtually nothing, but only if they're willing to pay a handsome salary to roll the dice on those loud tools and risk wrecking a clubhouse culture in which the organization takes fierce pride. Somewhere and sometime this winter, though, the Cubs will have to take a big risk. They can do it by spending $100 million on Sato, or on Kaima Taira and his unique pitching frame. They can do it by paying Trevor Rogers like a near-ace, even though he's only pieced together two partial seasons of being such a hurler over a relatively long career. Another option is to bet on Duran's obvious talent and immense potential, and to hope the team's culture influences him, instead of things working the opposite way. Duran was effusive in his praise of Alex Bregman as a teammate and mentor, even after Bregman left the Red Sox to sign with the Cubs last winter. It might well be that a reunion with Bregman could help the outfielder get his groove back—not only in terms of being more focused and disciplined in his behavior, but in the at-bats he takes and the resulting production on the field. Pete Crow-Armstrong clearly benefited from Bregman's presence on the Cubs in 2026. That was visible, but it was also something Crow-Armstrong spoke to directly. Duran's approach at the plate turned his season far more sour than any of his off-field frustrations could. Bregman is the kind of teammate who helps other players improve on that score, and there's already evidence that he and Duran can work well together. The Cubs have a shoddy history of taking into consideration their fans from the LGBTQ+ community. They traded for Daniel Murphy in 2018, and treated objections to that move with unfortunate dismissiveness. Far too often, they have used owner Laura Ricketts (who is gay) as a shield against accusations of insensitivity to questions of inclusiveness, and her approval was used as a deflection for criticism of the trade. The team sends mixed signals to its fans about how welcome and included women, people of color and LGBTQ+ folks should feel. Bringing in Duran would risk exacerbating that state of affairs. However, room should also be made for second chances, and teams can't apply tests of worldview or perfect behavior to every possible transaction. If they did, many, many of the game's stars would have to be ruled out. If they bring in Duran, they need to have a better plan for the process of introducing him to their fans, including preparing him for questions about his 2024 transgression. They should ensure that he harbors genuine remorse for those actions, which was never in evidence with Murphy. They also need to be sure that they can help him become more effective and more positive in his relationships. That's a lot to hope for, for a player who might need to be picked up in an under-the-wire trade or snatched quickly from the free-agent scrap heap. It might all be more trouble than it's worth. There's a strong argument for spending the extra millions on Sato, if they can manage it. However, few players available this offseason have the impact potential of Duran. If the team's background work (via Bregman; via the organization's familiarity with Red Sox president of baseball operations Craig Breslow; or via whatever other channels are available) tells them he has a good chance of realizing that upside based on his on- and off-field approaches, they're right to seriously consider the gamble. Image courtesy of Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images View full article
-
I hear you. I agree with @mul21 that you're dooming a little too hard on the rotation, but I also think you've actually undershot what filling their needs via free agency would cost. Think more like $330 million in CBT spend. I would guess they attack it a bit more through trade and with some small FA moves, rather than swinging big on many free-agent pursuits. If you feel that's insufficient, I understand, but I think the solution you propose would be phenomenally difficult logistically (getting that many guys in a competitive marketplace where supply is limited is hard!) and so much more expensive than you're suggesting that it's probably impossible. Realistically, I don't think there's any way they can project to win 95 games going into next year, and I very much doubt that'll be their goal. Instead, they'll try to rearrange and better balance their roster; spend where they can; and go in with an 87-win projection or something, hoping to outperform that and/or improve along the way, via prospect promotions or the trade deadline. To put it succinctly: I think you're wrong that ownership or the FO could will them back to the top of the heap, even if they wanted to. But I think you're right to question how much they're even willing to risk in the attempt.
-
Being a starting pitcher in the majors leagues really is, in a way, like flying. It's an incredible feat of engineering. It can only be sustained for so long, even with the marvels of modern technology. And you need a clear runway to get off the ground. Taylor Clarke never had a smooth enough runway to gather speed and lift off. He came close. After being a third-round pick by the Diamondbacks in 2015, Clarke had three full, healthy seasons in the minors, working as a starter the whole time. He never became a top-100 starter on the national landscape or anything, but he progressed to Triple-A and emerged as a legitimate candidate to start for Arizona. In fact, he started 20 games and spent about half of both the 2019 and 2020 seasons in the rotation. Things didn't go terribly well, but those seasons were badly distorted—by the most homer-happy season in league history, and then by a global pandemic. That was enough, though. Those few bumps slowed Clarke down, just as he needed to gather the last bit of speed and put the wind on the right side of his wing flaps. That's when injuries hit him, like obstacles on the runway. From 2021 through 2024, his campaigns were interrupted or derailed by injuries to his shoulder, oblique, elbow and knee. None of them were exceptionally severe. He underwent Tommy John surgery, but it was way back in college, in 2013. For the most part, Clarke has been an impressively durable arm. However, that lost momentum a half-decade ago (and the fact that was out of options) forced him to the bullpen. Healthy at last, he thrived there in 2025 and 2026. Clarke has been released three times and traded once, so although he pitched in 2026 with the same team that drafted him 11 years ago, it was after stints in the Kansas City and Milwaukee organizations. He spent all of 2024 in the minors with the Brewers, working mostly as a starter, but that only confirmed for him that his path to a big-league job was working in relief. With the Royals in 2025 and Diamondbacks in 2026, he did just that, and the results have been superb. Since the start of 2025, Clarke has pitched in 122 big-league games, all (essentially) in relief. He's compiled 128 1/3 innings, with a 73 ERA-, a 94 FIP- and a 4.7% walk rate. He doesn't miss as many bats as one would prefer, at least in his current form, but he's been very durable and very sturdy. As a reliever, Clarke throws roughly 95 miles per hour with his sinker. The real story, though, is that he switched from a four-seamer to a cutter in 2026, and he was still able to throw the pitch at 94 MPH. A cutter that firm—especially playing off his tight slider, which averages 88-89 MPH—is a major weapon, and it had much to do with the way Clarke got batters out in his walk year. Having discovered this pitch, he's better equipped to keep the ball in the park and fill up the zone than ever before. Clarke will have a strong enough market this winter to ensure a big-league deal. It's easy to stand out from whatever crowd of teams lines up to bid for him, though: Offer him a chance to start. He'll turn 34 next May; he's not a traditional candidate to move back to the rotation. His stuff is good enough to make that possible, though. Starting again, he might lose a tick on the fastballs, but he's shown good enough feel for his stuff to find ways around whatever problems that raises. He could ratchet the usage of his four-seamer back up, to achieve a true three-fastball mix. His slider and changeup are good offerings. He should be able to get out both left- and right-handed batters. And if the experiment of re-converting doesn't pan out, he could always help in the bullpen. The Cubs need three starting pitchers well clear of Clarke's level. They also need to reinforce their bullpen. But depth is almost as big a problem as upside for this staff, and Clarke offers a low-cost way to address it. He might even have more upside than meets the eye.
-
Being a starting pitcher in the majors leagues really is, in a way, like flying. It's an incredible feat of engineering. It can only be sustained for so long, even with the marvels of modern technology. And you need a clear runway to get off the ground. Taylor Clarke never had a smooth enough runway to gather speed and lift off. He came close. After being a third-round pick by the Diamondbacks in 2015, Clarke had three full, healthy seasons in the minors, working as a starter the whole time. He never became a top-100 starter on the national landscape or anything, but he progressed to Triple-A and emerged as a legitimate candidate to start for Arizona. In fact, he started 20 games and spent about half of both the 2019 and 2020 seasons in the rotation. Things didn't go terribly well, but those seasons were badly distorted—by the most homer-happy season in league history, and then by a global pandemic. That was enough, though. Those few bumps slowed Clarke down, just as he needed to gather the last bit of speed and put the wind on the right side of his wing flaps. That's when injuries hit him, like obstacles on the runway. From 2021 through 2024, his campaigns were interrupted or derailed by injuries to his shoulder, oblique, elbow and knee. None of them were exceptionally severe. He underwent Tommy John surgery, but it was way back in college, in 2013. For the most part, Clarke has been an impressively durable arm. However, that lost momentum a half-decade ago (and the fact that was out of options) forced him to the bullpen. Healthy at last, he thrived there in 2025 and 2026. Clarke has been released three times and traded once, so although he pitched in 2026 with the same team that drafted him 11 years ago, it was after stints in the Kansas City and Milwaukee organizations. He spent all of 2024 in the minors with the Brewers, working mostly as a starter, but that only confirmed for him that his path to a big-league job was working in relief. With the Royals in 2025 and Diamondbacks in 2026, he did just that, and the results have been superb. Since the start of 2025, Clarke has pitched in 122 big-league games, all (essentially) in relief. He's compiled 128 1/3 innings, with a 73 ERA-, a 94 FIP- and a 4.7% walk rate. He doesn't miss as many bats as one would prefer, at least in his current form, but he's been very durable and very sturdy. As a reliever, Clarke throws roughly 95 miles per hour with his sinker. The real story, though, is that he switched from a four-seamer to a cutter in 2026, and he was still able to throw the pitch at 94 MPH. A cutter that firm—especially playing off his tight slider, which averages 88-89 MPH—is a major weapon, and it had much to do with the way Clarke got batters out in his walk year. Having discovered this pitch, he's better equipped to keep the ball in the park and fill up the zone than ever before. Clarke will have a strong enough market this winter to ensure a big-league deal. It's easy to stand out from whatever crowd of teams lines up to bid for him, though: Offer him a chance to start. He'll turn 34 next May; he's not a traditional candidate to move back to the rotation. His stuff is good enough to make that possible, though. Starting again, he might lose a tick on the fastballs, but he's shown good enough feel for his stuff to find ways around whatever problems that raises. He could ratchet the usage of his four-seamer back up, to achieve a true three-fastball mix. His slider and changeup are good offerings. He should be able to get out both left- and right-handed batters. And if the experiment of re-converting doesn't pan out, he could always help in the bullpen. The Cubs need three starting pitchers well clear of Clarke's level. They also need to reinforce their bullpen. But depth is almost as big a problem as upside for this staff, and Clarke offers a low-cost way to address it. He might even have more upside than meets the eye. Image courtesy of David Frerker-Imagn Images View full article
-
The Chicago Cubs were interested in Dustin May, but were unwilling to guarantee a third year in their pursuit of the right-handed starter, according to a source familiar with the team's thinking. May got that third year, instead, on the other side of town, agreeing to a three-year deal Tuesday morning worth $52.5 million. The $17.5-million annual average value (AAV) of the deal feels high, given that May ended the season as a little-trusted fourth starter for the Brewers and that he has ERAs of 4.96 and 4.70 over the last two years. What drew the Cubs to him was the same thing that ultimately led the Sox to push in the extra year and win the bidding war, though: he was (by far) the hardest-throwing starting pitcher not named Tarik Skubal on the market. May's four-seamer and sinker each average over 96 miles per hour. Late in the season, Rays starter Freddy Peralta showed that level of heat, too, but Peralta's multi-year track record shows less heat, and he's not as likely to sustain that velocity over a full season as is May. Peralta is still a better pitcher, and he'll sign for considerably more than May, but the fact that May's sheer power exceeds even Peralta's explains why several teams took a keen interest in him. The ABS system shrunk the strike zone in 2026. That increased the relative value of stuff and forced teams to think about how they can find pitchers who miss bats and induce weak contact despite hitters having a smaller zone to cover. May hasn't proved he can execute well enough to dominate consistently, but unlike many available starters, he has the raw materials to do so. That boosted his market. One Cubs Pitching Target: Sean Newcomb Having missed out on May, the Cubs have to pivot to other options. Peralta is on their radar. So is Trevor Rogers. One less-heralded name could be an easy way for the North Siders to turn the tables on the White Sox, in a sense. Chicago has checked in on left-hander Sean Newcomb, a source said, and maintains active interest in him. Newcomb has only started 11 of the 108 games in which he's appeared since the start of 2025, but he has 182 2/3 innings pitched over that span, often working multiple innings even when appearing in relief. Newcomb has a 22.9% strikeout rate and an 8.5% walk rate over those two seasons, and he's kept the ball in the park exceptionally well. How? He induces weaker contact than most pitchers, largely because he throws hard. Among free-agent pitchers with any chance to be starters in 2027, only Skubal and May threw harder in 2026 than did Newcomb. He sits around 95 MPH with his four-seamer and 93.5 MPH with his heavy sinker. If he were to stretch back out as a traditional starter, those numbers might come down slightly, but they're good enough to be good offerings even if that happens. His slurve is a good complement to those offerings, thanks to his plus command of it. Newcomb would be a solid pickup for a Cubs team wide huge and varied pitching needs. May's deal underscores, however, that even Newcomb won't be cheap. One source suggested he could command a two-year deal with an AAV over $10 million, even heading into his age-34 season. Given what May just got, that would hardly be a surprise. The market is crystallizing, and the Cubs are beginning to see that there's no way to cure what ails them without spending big money. Why Nick Fortes Has Emerged as Fit for Cubs' Catching Need Two more consequential moves Tuesday afternoon drove home the same point. David Bednar accepted the qualifying offer the Yankees had extended him at the beginning of the month, taking one of the top two relief arms off the market. Ryan Jeffers did the same with the Twins, pushing Carson Kelly to the top of the free-agent catching class. Jeffers will make $23.15 million in 2027. Kelly isn't as good a hitter as Jeffers, but he's a much better defender, and he's caught 25% more innings over the last two seasons than Jeffers has. It looks increasingly likely that Kelly, too, will get at least $20 million in guaranteed money somewhere this winter. In all likelihood, the Cubs will (and should) pass on bringing back Kelly at that steep a price. That's why they were among the teams to talk to the Rays Tuesday about catcher Nick Fortes, who still might be traded before Friday's deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players. Fortes, 30, has added bat speed and become more aggressive since joining the Rays at the 2025 trade deadline. He still only batted .258/.304/.376 in 323 plate appearances for the American League champions in 2026, but he’s a well-rounded and respected defensive backstop, and he’s under team control for 2028, as well as the coming season. According to MLB Trade Rumors, he’s likely to earn around $3.4 million next year via arbitration. Offensively, the aging profile isn’t encouraging. Fortes minimizes strikeouts thanks to great feel for making contact on pitches outside the zone, but that’s tended to interfere with the production of power numbers that match his raw power skills. He swings outside the zone too much to draw many walks, too. In the short term, though, he’s a pesky hitter who can run into a ball now and then thanks to a very flat, surprisingly quick stick. Behind the plate, he’s an average-minus framer, but he throws well and has a good reputation with pitchers. He made a couple of head-scratching calls for pitches on which Rays hurlers got burned in October, but on the whole, he’s considered a good reader of the game and a solid adherent to the gameplans his teams have put together to get outs. He also rated as average (or slightly better) when it came to challenging calls via the ABS system in 2026. One way or another, the Cubs have to reinforce their catching corps, but Jeffers was never on their radar. His re-up with the Twins illustrates the difficulty they'll have if they choose to re-sign Kelly, though. They need big money to bolster their pitching staff. A pickup like Fortes feels almost imperative, given the circumstances. If May costs $17 million a year and the going rate for elite players in small roles like Bednar's and Jeffers's is over $20 million, the five or six additions the Cubs need to make figure to require $100 million in 2027 outlays alone—or an equivalent expenditure of young talent, from a farm system that doesn't have much to lose or to offer. Chicago was never quite a favorite on May, and neither Jeffers nor Bednar were ever destined to join them. With May, Evan Phillips and Jake Bauers (all solid potential targets) off the board already, though, a high-priced market is coming into focus, and the Cubs need to reduce their desperation by finding a fit or two soon. Otherwise, they might end up making big mistakes at the tail end of this month, or after the looming lockout.
- 1 comment
-
- david bednar
- ryan jeffers
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
The Chicago Cubs were interested in Dustin May, but were unwilling to guarantee a third year in their pursuit of the right-handed starter, according to a source familiar with the team's thinking. May got that third year, instead, on the other side of town, agreeing to a three-year deal Tuesday morning worth $52.5 million. The $17.5-million annual average value (AAV) of the deal feels high, given that May ended the season as a little-trusted fourth starter for the Brewers and that he has ERAs of 4.96 and 4.70 over the last two years. What drew the Cubs to him was the same thing that ultimately led the Sox to push in the extra year and win the bidding war, though: he was (by far) the hardest-throwing starting pitcher not named Tarik Skubal on the market. May's four-seamer and sinker each average over 96 miles per hour. Late in the season, Rays starter Freddy Peralta showed that level of heat, too, but Peralta's multi-year track record shows less heat, and he's not as likely to sustain that velocity over a full season as is May. Peralta is still a better pitcher, and he'll sign for considerably more than May, but the fact that May's sheer power exceeds even Peralta's explains why several teams took a keen interest in him. The ABS system shrunk the strike zone in 2026. That increased the relative value of stuff and forced teams to think about how they can find pitchers who miss bats and induce weak contact despite hitters having a smaller zone to cover. May hasn't proved he can execute well enough to dominate consistently, but unlike many available starters, he has the raw materials to do so. That boosted his market. One Cubs Pitching Target: Sean Newcomb Having missed out on May, the Cubs have to pivot to other options. Peralta is on their radar. So is Trevor Rogers. One less-heralded name could be an easy way for the North Siders to turn the tables on the White Sox, in a sense. Chicago has checked in on left-hander Sean Newcomb, a source said, and maintains active interest in him. Newcomb has only started 11 of the 108 games in which he's appeared since the start of 2025, but he has 182 2/3 innings pitched over that span, often working multiple innings even when appearing in relief. Newcomb has a 22.9% strikeout rate and an 8.5% walk rate over those two seasons, and he's kept the ball in the park exceptionally well. How? He induces weaker contact than most pitchers, largely because he throws hard. Among free-agent pitchers with any chance to be starters in 2027, only Skubal and May threw harder in 2026 than did Newcomb. He sits around 95 MPH with his four-seamer and 93.5 MPH with his heavy sinker. If he were to stretch back out as a traditional starter, those numbers might come down slightly, but they're good enough to be good offerings even if that happens. His slurve is a good complement to those offerings, thanks to his plus command of it. Newcomb would be a solid pickup for a Cubs team wide huge and varied pitching needs. May's deal underscores, however, that even Newcomb won't be cheap. One source suggested he could command a two-year deal with an AAV over $10 million, even heading into his age-34 season. Given what May just got, that would hardly be a surprise. The market is crystallizing, and the Cubs are beginning to see that there's no way to cure what ails them without spending big money. Why Nick Fortes Has Emerged as Fit for Cubs' Catching Need Two more consequential moves Tuesday afternoon drove home the same point. David Bednar accepted the qualifying offer the Yankees had extended him at the beginning of the month, taking one of the top two relief arms off the market. Ryan Jeffers did the same with the Twins, pushing Carson Kelly to the top of the free-agent catching class. Jeffers will make $23.15 million in 2027. Kelly isn't as good a hitter as Jeffers, but he's a much better defender, and he's caught 25% more innings over the last two seasons than Jeffers has. It looks increasingly likely that Kelly, too, will get at least $20 million in guaranteed money somewhere this winter. In all likelihood, the Cubs will (and should) pass on bringing back Kelly at that steep a price. That's why they were among the teams to talk to the Rays Tuesday about catcher Nick Fortes, who still might be traded before Friday's deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players. Fortes, 30, has added bat speed and become more aggressive since joining the Rays at the 2025 trade deadline. He still only batted .258/.304/.376 in 323 plate appearances for the American League champions in 2026, but he’s a well-rounded and respected defensive backstop, and he’s under team control for 2028, as well as the coming season. According to MLB Trade Rumors, he’s likely to earn around $3.4 million next year via arbitration. Offensively, the aging profile isn’t encouraging. Fortes minimizes strikeouts thanks to great feel for making contact on pitches outside the zone, but that’s tended to interfere with the production of power numbers that match his raw power skills. He swings outside the zone too much to draw many walks, too. In the short term, though, he’s a pesky hitter who can run into a ball now and then thanks to a very flat, surprisingly quick stick. Behind the plate, he’s an average-minus framer, but he throws well and has a good reputation with pitchers. He made a couple of head-scratching calls for pitches on which Rays hurlers got burned in October, but on the whole, he’s considered a good reader of the game and a solid adherent to the gameplans his teams have put together to get outs. He also rated as average (or slightly better) when it came to challenging calls via the ABS system in 2026. One way or another, the Cubs have to reinforce their catching corps, but Jeffers was never on their radar. His re-up with the Twins illustrates the difficulty they'll have if they choose to re-sign Kelly, though. They need big money to bolster their pitching staff. A pickup like Fortes feels almost imperative, given the circumstances. If May costs $17 million a year and the going rate for elite players in small roles like Bednar's and Jeffers's is over $20 million, the five or six additions the Cubs need to make figure to require $100 million in 2027 outlays alone—or an equivalent expenditure of young talent, from a farm system that doesn't have much to lose or to offer. Chicago was never quite a favorite on May, and neither Jeffers nor Bednar were ever destined to join them. With May, Evan Phillips and Jake Bauers (all solid potential targets) off the board already, though, a high-priced market is coming into focus, and the Cubs need to reduce their desperation by finding a fit or two soon. Otherwise, they might end up making big mistakes at the tail end of this month, or after the looming lockout. Image courtesy of Benny Sieu-Imagn Images View full article
- 1 reply
-
- david bednar
- ryan jeffers
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Cubs Add Jaxon Wiggins, Brody McCullough to 40-Man Roster
Matthew Trueblood posted an article in Cubs
There might not be a Rule 5 Draft this offseason. Because of the upcoming lockout by the owners, the annual Winter Meetings are expected to be canceled; the Rule 5 Draft customarily happens at the end of those Meetings. When the last collective bargaining agreement expired and the league plunged into a lockout in 2021 (leading into 2022), the draft was eventually canceled. Some expect that to happen again this time around. Few teams behaved as though they could count on that, though. The Cubs, for one, added top pitching prospect Jaxon Wiggins to their 40-man roster, and kept going with righty Brody McCullough, who will serve as a depth option for the starting rotation and the bullpen in 2027. Chicago had six vacancies on their 40-man roster, and though they're likely to add players via trade and free agency in the next two weeks, they can also drop multiple players before the deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players Friday. Adding Wiggins and McCullough protects the organization's pitching depth (such as it is) and comes at virtually no opportunity cost. A handful of Cubs prospects did become eligible for the draft upon being left unprotected Tuesday evening, headlined by relief prospect Grant Kipp and second baseman/outfielder Jose Cabrera. It's unlikely the team will lose a significant player, though, even if the draft does take place. Wiggins and McCullough were easily the most important ones to keep, given the team's short-term needs. Chicago also talked about multiple trades throughout the day, according to sources familiar with the discussions, some of which could be revisited later this week. They're among the teams who checked in with the Rays on catcher Nick Fortes, whom the team still might move before Friday's deadline, and they engaged multiple teams (including the Boston Red Sox) on pitchers who would supplement the starting depth and might end up in long relief. -
There might not be a Rule 5 Draft this offseason. Because of the upcoming lockout by the owners, the annual Winter Meetings are expected to be canceled; the Rule 5 Draft customarily happens at the end of those Meetings. When the last collective bargaining agreement expired and the league plunged into a lockout in 2021 (leading into 2022), the draft was eventually canceled. Some expect that to happen again this time around. Few teams behaved as though they could count on that, though. The Cubs, for one, added top pitching prospect Jaxon Wiggins to their 40-man roster, and kept going with righty Brody McCullough, who will serve as a depth option for the starting rotation and the bullpen in 2027. Chicago had six vacancies on their 40-man roster, and though they're likely to add players via trade and free agency in the next two weeks, they can also drop multiple players before the deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players Friday. Adding Wiggins and McCullough protects the organization's pitching depth (such as it is) and comes at virtually no opportunity cost. A handful of Cubs prospects did become eligible for the draft upon being left unprotected Tuesday evening, headlined by relief prospect Grant Kipp and second baseman/outfielder Jose Cabrera. It's unlikely the team will lose a significant player, though, even if the draft does take place. Wiggins and McCullough were easily the most important ones to keep, given the team's short-term needs. Chicago also talked about multiple trades throughout the day, according to sources familiar with the discussions, some of which could be revisited later this week. They're among the teams who checked in with the Rays on catcher Nick Fortes, whom the team still might move before Friday's deadline, and they engaged multiple teams (including the Boston Red Sox) on pitchers who would supplement the starting depth and might end up in long relief. Image courtesy of Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images View full article
-
Michael Busch didn't hit lefties badly at all in 2026; that wasn't the problem. In 204 plate appearances, the lefty batter hit .243/.348/.422 against southpaws, marking a big improvement from his more limited work against them in 2025. However, many of the adjustments Busch made (to his stance, to his contact point, and to his approach) to handle becoming an everyday player made him less effective against right-handed pitchers. He hit .272/.356/.554 against them in 2025; those numbers fell to .241/.354/.382 in 2026. Most of any batter's plate appearances come against righties, of course, so by losing so much against them, Busch suffered a huge net loss, despite his big progress against lefties. If at all possible, the Cubs need to un-ring the bell in 2027. Busch should return to a modified platoon role, getting 550 or more plate appearances but far short of 700, with strict instructions to restore the setup and attack he utilized in 2025. That might prove a losing battle, and 2025 might end up looking like a career year for a player limited by his unimposing stature and below-average bat speed, but the team has to try it. To do so, though, they also need to find a reliable platoon partner for him. The person they sign need not start against all lefties, and they need not be a pure first baseman. With Seiya Suzuki headed elsewhere via free agency, the team also has to backfill its designated hitter spot, and they've traded their top two bat-first prospects (Owen Caissie and Moisés Ballesteros) since the start of 2026. Here's a ranking of seven options to replace some of the production the team is losing in its corner outfield and DH spots, while also supporting Busch by releieving him of some responsibilities against lefties. We're going from most to least desirable. Jake Burger, Texas Rangers: Set to make roughly $7 million via arbitration this winter, Burger might become a luxury the cost-cutting Rangers prefer not to afford. He's about as unvarnished an opposite of Busch as you can find: right-handed, thickly built, with a very aggressive approach at the plate and plus-plus bat speed. However, he's also surprisingly nimble at first base and a good receiver of errant throws. He batted .228/.302/.421 in 2026, launching 28 homers, and his damage came disproportionately (.891 OPS) against lefties. He'd cost either $7 million and a low-level prospect or whatever the market bears, should the Rangers non-tender him, but he could be almost an everyday player, dividing his time between first base and DH. At 30,, he's not likely to plunge into decline in 2027, either. Some guys on this list can't say that. He would even come with an extra year of club control, in 2028. Paul Goldschmidt, Free Agent: Probably not a future Hall of Famer, Goldschmidt is as good as you can be without having that label slapped on you. He's had an unexpectedly graceful and valuable final act in his career, too, going to the Yankes and serving as a solid (though far from spectacular) lefty-mashing platoon guy. Even at the brink of turning 40, he's a plus defender at the cold corner. He'd be an excellent addition to the clubhouse, and offensively, he's more than the sum of his parts. As the Cubs learned when they signed Justin Turner, though, even great hitters are vulnerable to sudden collapse at this age. He'd cost a fair bit of money, the same way Turner did, but he's a better bet than Turner was. Josh Bell, Free Agent: The Twins signed Bell to a one-year deal to help them at first base last winter, and by the end of April, they had essentially given up on that idea and moved him to DH full-time. A switch-hitter with a balanced offensive skill set, Bell is just too huge a human to move nimbly around the base or get low quickly on grounders. He does everything fairly well at the plate, is a beloved teammate, and even gets a bit frisky on the bases at times, despite very little raw speed. He'd be more of a DH than a first baseman, but he could at least spell Busch as part of a larger role, and he's likely to come at a low price given what he can do at the plate. Royce Lewis, Minnesota Twins: Another Minnesota alumnus, Lewis is still under team control, but he's at least as likely to be non-tendered as Burger is. As recently as mid-May, he was a third baseman, but he has the right long-limbed build to be a plus first baseman, and he showed some flashes of that down the stretch. What he did not show, even after a reset in the minor leagues, was the consistent ability to hit the way a first baseman must. Lewis is also a former first overall pick with a high opinion of his own game and his future, so before acquiring him (in whatever fashion), the Cubs would need to make sure that he's on board with a reduced, complementary role. Ryan Mountcastle, Free Agent: There are big red flags with Mountcastle, whose profile at the plate is all-or-nothing as it gets. He has elite bat speed, but his swing is grooved and his approach is overly aggressive. He came up as a shortstop, and still shows some athleticism as a first baseman, so his defense won't hurt you. However, his bat can't carry more than a part-time role, and even then, you're betting on him getting back to mashing lefties consistently for the first time in multiple years. Eugenio Suárez, Free Agent: In the past, teams have profited nicely from buying low on Suárez, who's had a very up-and-down career but (as Cubs fans well know) can be a very dangerous righty slugger when he's on. Eventually, however, it becomes a bad bet to keep expecting him to recover from dips. Suárez has played first base only a few times over his long career, and might not be comfortable there at all, so he'd fit mostly as a DH. His value is very limited in that role, especially for the Cubs. Rhys Hoskins, Free Agent: Three players on this list are older than Hoskins, but none of them play older. A shadow of his Phillies self ever since the torn ACL that sidelined him for all of 2023, Hoskins has become a fairly desperate take-and-rake guy, trying to pull home runs right down the left-field line and taking as many walks as he can coerce from opposing pitchers. That's not a promising profile, especially as he projects to lose what little bat speed he has left in his mid-30s. He's heavy-footed at first base, too. There aren't perfect solutions to the Cubs' problems available this winter. If they add one of the top three players from this list, they're likely to be pleased with the returns, but each would force a slightly different set of choices about their other positional needs. If they have to go lower than that, the risks rise quickly, and offensive decline becomes increasingly likely for what is a very veteran team. They can't afford that, so if they don't splurge for one of the top-tier names here, they had better have unexpectedly grand plans for their other lineup holes. Image courtesy of Kelley L Cox-Imagn Images View full article
- 1 reply
-
- royce lewis
- paul goldschmidt
- (and 6 more)
-
Ranking Cubs' 7 Best Options for Right-Handed First Base and DH Help
Matthew Trueblood posted an article in Cubs
Michael Busch didn't hit lefties badly at all in 2026; that wasn't the problem. In 204 plate appearances, the lefty batter hit .243/.348/.422 against southpaws, marking a big improvement from his more limited work against them in 2025. However, many of the adjustments Busch made (to his stance, to his contact point, and to his approach) to handle becoming an everyday player made him less effective against right-handed pitchers. He hit .272/.356/.554 against them in 2025; those numbers fell to .241/.354/.382 in 2026. Most of any batter's plate appearances come against righties, of course, so by losing so much against them, Busch suffered a huge net loss, despite his big progress against lefties. If at all possible, the Cubs need to un-ring the bell in 2027. Busch should return to a modified platoon role, getting 550 or more plate appearances but far short of 700, with strict instructions to restore the setup and attack he utilized in 2025. That might prove a losing battle, and 2025 might end up looking like a career year for a player limited by his unimposing stature and below-average bat speed, but the team has to try it. To do so, though, they also need to find a reliable platoon partner for him. The person they sign need not start against all lefties, and they need not be a pure first baseman. With Seiya Suzuki headed elsewhere via free agency, the team also has to backfill its designated hitter spot, and they've traded their top two bat-first prospects (Owen Caissie and Moisés Ballesteros) since the start of 2026. Here's a ranking of seven options to replace some of the production the team is losing in its corner outfield and DH spots, while also supporting Busch by releieving him of some responsibilities against lefties. We're going from most to least desirable. Jake Burger, Texas Rangers: Set to make roughly $7 million via arbitration this winter, Burger might become a luxury the cost-cutting Rangers prefer not to afford. He's about as unvarnished an opposite of Busch as you can find: right-handed, thickly built, with a very aggressive approach at the plate and plus-plus bat speed. However, he's also surprisingly nimble at first base and a good receiver of errant throws. He batted .228/.302/.421 in 2026, launching 28 homers, and his damage came disproportionately (.891 OPS) against lefties. He'd cost either $7 million and a low-level prospect or whatever the market bears, should the Rangers non-tender him, but he could be almost an everyday player, dividing his time between first base and DH. At 30,, he's not likely to plunge into decline in 2027, either. Some guys on this list can't say that. He would even come with an extra year of club control, in 2028. Paul Goldschmidt, Free Agent: Probably not a future Hall of Famer, Goldschmidt is as good as you can be without having that label slapped on you. He's had an unexpectedly graceful and valuable final act in his career, too, going to the Yankes and serving as a solid (though far from spectacular) lefty-mashing platoon guy. Even at the brink of turning 40, he's a plus defender at the cold corner. He'd be an excellent addition to the clubhouse, and offensively, he's more than the sum of his parts. As the Cubs learned when they signed Justin Turner, though, even great hitters are vulnerable to sudden collapse at this age. He'd cost a fair bit of money, the same way Turner did, but he's a better bet than Turner was. Josh Bell, Free Agent: The Twins signed Bell to a one-year deal to help them at first base last winter, and by the end of April, they had essentially given up on that idea and moved him to DH full-time. A switch-hitter with a balanced offensive skill set, Bell is just too huge a human to move nimbly around the base or get low quickly on grounders. He does everything fairly well at the plate, is a beloved teammate, and even gets a bit frisky on the bases at times, despite very little raw speed. He'd be more of a DH than a first baseman, but he could at least spell Busch as part of a larger role, and he's likely to come at a low price given what he can do at the plate. Royce Lewis, Minnesota Twins: Another Minnesota alumnus, Lewis is still under team control, but he's at least as likely to be non-tendered as Burger is. As recently as mid-May, he was a third baseman, but he has the right long-limbed build to be a plus first baseman, and he showed some flashes of that down the stretch. What he did not show, even after a reset in the minor leagues, was the consistent ability to hit the way a first baseman must. Lewis is also a former first overall pick with a high opinion of his own game and his future, so before acquiring him (in whatever fashion), the Cubs would need to make sure that he's on board with a reduced, complementary role. Ryan Mountcastle, Free Agent: There are big red flags with Mountcastle, whose profile at the plate is all-or-nothing as it gets. He has elite bat speed, but his swing is grooved and his approach is overly aggressive. He came up as a shortstop, and still shows some athleticism as a first baseman, so his defense won't hurt you. However, his bat can't carry more than a part-time role, and even then, you're betting on him getting back to mashing lefties consistently for the first time in multiple years. Eugenio Suárez, Free Agent: In the past, teams have profited nicely from buying low on Suárez, who's had a very up-and-down career but (as Cubs fans well know) can be a very dangerous righty slugger when he's on. Eventually, however, it becomes a bad bet to keep expecting him to recover from dips. Suárez has played first base only a few times over his long career, and might not be comfortable there at all, so he'd fit mostly as a DH. His value is very limited in that role, especially for the Cubs. Rhys Hoskins, Free Agent: Three players on this list are older than Hoskins, but none of them play older. A shadow of his Phillies self ever since the torn ACL that sidelined him for all of 2023, Hoskins has become a fairly desperate take-and-rake guy, trying to pull home runs right down the left-field line and taking as many walks as he can coerce from opposing pitchers. That's not a promising profile, especially as he projects to lose what little bat speed he has left in his mid-30s. He's heavy-footed at first base, too. There aren't perfect solutions to the Cubs' problems available this winter. If they add one of the top three players from this list, they're likely to be pleased with the returns, but each would force a slightly different set of choices about their other positional needs. If they have to go lower than that, the risks rise quickly, and offensive decline becomes increasingly likely for what is a very veteran team. They can't afford that, so if they don't splurge for one of the top-tier names here, they had better have unexpectedly grand plans for their other lineup holes.- 1 comment
-
- royce lewis
- paul goldschmidt
- (and 6 more)
-
A year ago, neither Ben Malgeri nor Brett Callahan were even on most people's radar. FanGraphs ranked and gave reports on 34 Tigers prospects in 2023; 31 in 2024; 39 in 2025; and 47 in 2026. Malgeri and Callahan didn't show up on any of those lists. Malgeri, who will turn 27 in January, was an 18th-round pick in 2021 out of Northeastern. Callahan, 25, was a 13th-round pick in 2023 out of St. Joseph's. The Tigers have done a superb job scouting the northeastern corner of the country over the last handful of seasons, but not even they thought they had very much in either player. In 2026, however, those two virtual unknowns combined for 240 big-league plate appearances. Malgeria was good; Callahan was bad. But each earned an unexpected opportunity, not just because the Tigers had a massively disappointing season, but because they played exceptionally well in the minors. Callahan had 416 plate appearances in 96 games at the top two levels in the minor leagues, batting .269/.365/.443. He hit 13 home runs there, and stole 29 bases in 35 tries. Most of that production dried up when he got to the bigs, but it was a clear step forward—and maybe more. A left-handed batter, Callahan is a plus runner with plus raw power. He'll need a slightly more disciplined approach than he showed in his stint in the majors, but it's now fair to at least dream on (and maybe even realistically hope for) a career as a mid-tier platoon outfielder. The news on Malgeri might be even better. He's older, but he hit .296/.401/.496 in 297 plate appearances at Triple-A Toledo, earning a promotion to the majors. In 437 total tripe to the plate, he had 14 home runs and 13 stolen bases. He's a step faster than Callahan, and has a stronger arm, so he's a plus right fielder. His bat speed is below-average, but his approach is far more patient (and his feel for the barrel much better) than Callahan's. He bats right-handed, so he has to be a bit better to survive in a big role, but he just might clear that bar. Though they might be a bit wary about sudden success from prospects without pedigree, most teams would feel very lucky to have players like Callahan and Malgeri, and it might be hard to pry them away. Detroit is in a unique position, though. They also promoted and installed a much higher-caliber outfield prospect late in the season, in 2023 first-round pick Max Clark. He'll be their regular center fielder in 2027, and All-Star slugger Riley Greene is poised to flank him in left field. They also traded for top prospect Zyhir Hope at the deadline, as the co-headliner of the Tarik Skubal deal. In addition to those three, Detroit has slugger Kerry Carpenter, who (like Green) is still under team control for two more seasons. They have defensive whiz Parker Meadows, utility man Matt Vierling and the even more versatile Zach McKinstry. Like Carpenter, Wenceel Pérez had a tough 2026, but he's still a talented piece, too. The Cubs are looking to add at least one outfielder this winter. Ideally, they'd add two, to replace the departing Ian Happ and Seiya Suzuki. Callahan and Malgeri, although low-profile, low-cost, low-ceiling pickups, would be under team control for six more seasons, and can be easily optioned to the minor leagues. Trading for either would keep all of Chicago's financial powder dry, and neither would cost them a top prospect. It would just be a matter of matching up properly. Detroit might yet decide to roll with a modified platoon of Callahan and Malgeri at one outfield spot next year. In that case, they might instead trade one of Greene and Carpenter, in whom the Cubs would surely have interest. Greene would be a top-tier way to replace Happ, though he's set to make a healthy $9.3 million in 2027 and would also cost the team a handsome prospect package. Carpenter would be an upside play, with his raw power and history of mashing right-handed pitching balancing out a lack of plate discipline or defensive value. One way or another, the Tigers are likely to move an outfielder, and they're likely to move them soon. Detroit's 40-man roster is full. The Cubs' has ample room for a player who can help them next season, even if it be in a somewhat limited role. The fit between the two is perfect, and Cubs executive Jed Hoyer and Tigers boss Scott Harris know each other as well as any two head baseball decision-makers in the game. It wouldn't be a surprise if the two of them got together on a deal early this week. Image courtesy of USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect View full article
- 2 replies
-
- ben malgeri
- brett callahan
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
In Cubs' Hunt for Outfield Help, Tigers Could Be Perfect Trade Partners
Matthew Trueblood posted an article in Cubs
A year ago, neither Ben Malgeri nor Brett Callahan were even on most people's radar. FanGraphs ranked and gave reports on 34 Tigers prospects in 2023; 31 in 2024; 39 in 2025; and 47 in 2026. Malgeri and Callahan didn't show up on any of those lists. Malgeri, who will turn 27 in January, was an 18th-round pick in 2021 out of Northeastern. Callahan, 25, was a 13th-round pick in 2023 out of St. Joseph's. The Tigers have done a superb job scouting the northeastern corner of the country over the last handful of seasons, but not even they thought they had very much in either player. In 2026, however, those two virtual unknowns combined for 240 big-league plate appearances. Malgeria was good; Callahan was bad. But each earned an unexpected opportunity, not just because the Tigers had a massively disappointing season, but because they played exceptionally well in the minors. Callahan had 416 plate appearances in 96 games at the top two levels in the minor leagues, batting .269/.365/.443. He hit 13 home runs there, and stole 29 bases in 35 tries. Most of that production dried up when he got to the bigs, but it was a clear step forward—and maybe more. A left-handed batter, Callahan is a plus runner with plus raw power. He'll need a slightly more disciplined approach than he showed in his stint in the majors, but it's now fair to at least dream on (and maybe even realistically hope for) a career as a mid-tier platoon outfielder. The news on Malgeri might be even better. He's older, but he hit .296/.401/.496 in 297 plate appearances at Triple-A Toledo, earning a promotion to the majors. In 437 total tripe to the plate, he had 14 home runs and 13 stolen bases. He's a step faster than Callahan, and has a stronger arm, so he's a plus right fielder. His bat speed is below-average, but his approach is far more patient (and his feel for the barrel much better) than Callahan's. He bats right-handed, so he has to be a bit better to survive in a big role, but he just might clear that bar. Though they might be a bit wary about sudden success from prospects without pedigree, most teams would feel very lucky to have players like Callahan and Malgeri, and it might be hard to pry them away. Detroit is in a unique position, though. They also promoted and installed a much higher-caliber outfield prospect late in the season, in 2023 first-round pick Max Clark. He'll be their regular center fielder in 2027, and All-Star slugger Riley Greene is poised to flank him in left field. They also traded for top prospect Zyhir Hope at the deadline, as the co-headliner of the Tarik Skubal deal. In addition to those three, Detroit has slugger Kerry Carpenter, who (like Green) is still under team control for two more seasons. They have defensive whiz Parker Meadows, utility man Matt Vierling and the even more versatile Zach McKinstry. Like Carpenter, Wenceel Pérez had a tough 2026, but he's still a talented piece, too. The Cubs are looking to add at least one outfielder this winter. Ideally, they'd add two, to replace the departing Ian Happ and Seiya Suzuki. Callahan and Malgeri, although low-profile, low-cost, low-ceiling pickups, would be under team control for six more seasons, and can be easily optioned to the minor leagues. Trading for either would keep all of Chicago's financial powder dry, and neither would cost them a top prospect. It would just be a matter of matching up properly. Detroit might yet decide to roll with a modified platoon of Callahan and Malgeri at one outfield spot next year. In that case, they might instead trade one of Greene and Carpenter, in whom the Cubs would surely have interest. Greene would be a top-tier way to replace Happ, though he's set to make a healthy $9.3 million in 2027 and would also cost the team a handsome prospect package. Carpenter would be an upside play, with his raw power and history of mashing right-handed pitching balancing out a lack of plate discipline or defensive value. One way or another, the Tigers are likely to move an outfielder, and they're likely to move them soon. Detroit's 40-man roster is full. The Cubs' has ample room for a player who can help them next season, even if it be in a somewhat limited role. The fit between the two is perfect, and Cubs executive Jed Hoyer and Tigers boss Scott Harris know each other as well as any two head baseball decision-makers in the game. It wouldn't be a surprise if the two of them got together on a deal early this week.- 2 comments
-
- ben malgeri
- brett callahan
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Cubs Will Be Busy Over Next Two Days, Likely to Make Multiple Moves
Matthew Trueblood posted an article in Cubs
As what figures to be a very busy week throughout baseball gets underway, the Cubs enjoy a minor but meaningful advantage. They have 34 players on their 40-man roster right now, while much of the league faces a more acute roster crunch. The Red Sox, Tigers, Athletics, Mets and Nationals all have full 40-man lists. The White Sox, Astros, Mariners, Giants, Cardinals and Rays are all at 39. When the offseason begins, players slough off rosters and into free agency, so most teams have at least a modicum of breathing room. In mid-November, though, the squeeze begins anew. By 5 PM CT Tuesday, teams must add any eligible minor leaguers not currently on their 40-man rosters to those lists to shield them from the Rule 5 Draft. Players who have completed at least (depending on their age when they entered pro ball) four or five professional seasons are eligible for the draft if not added to the 40-man. This year, there's a twist, because the Rule 5 Draft usually takes place at the end of the annual Winter Meetings. Those are expected to be canceled this year, as the league embarks on what figures to be a prolonged lockout. Last time there was an offseason lockout, in 2021 and 2022, the Rule 5 Draft was ultimately canceled. However, teams aren't planning on getting that reprieve again, according to multiple executives. That's why, for instance, the Giants and Brewers got together on a trade Sunday evening, sending right-handed reliever Ryan Walker to Milwaukee in exchange for two pitching prospects. One of those prospects is Blake Holub, whom the Brewers would have had to add to their 40-man roster to protect. As mentioned above, the Giants face a 40-man crunch, and it's not yet clear whether Holub will fit onto their roster. By moving Walker off that roster, though, they created a much-needed vacancy. There will be several more moves like that one throughout the league this week. As one of the teams with ample room on the 40-man (for now), Chicago is already active in discussions with teams who are feeling their crunch, league sources said Sunday night. That's not to suggest that they don't face a crunch of their own. The Cubs have to add Jaxon Wiggins to their 40-man roster to protect him from the draft, and although Wiggins had a dreadful 2026 and looks like a reliever-only prospect with major health questions, he still has a ceiling as a high-octane, high-leverage arm. Chicago will protect that upside. They're also almost certain to protect Jose Escobar, 22, a Venezuelan second baseman and outfielder who has only reached High-A South Bend but performed well there and could be on a fast track to the majors from here. After that, the decisions get tougher, but there are several of them. Injuries have left big questions about the utility of Triple-A starters Brody McCullough, Will Sanders and Brandon Birdsell, but for a team starved for pitching depth, leaving (especially) McCullough exposed would be uncomfortable. They might add McCullough, too, which would push the roster to 37 players. Sanders, Birdsell and outfielders Carter Trice and Alexey Lumpuy all are candidates to be traded to teams more likely to protect them, though none are likely to be taken even if left vulnerable to it. The closest comp the Cubs have to Brewers-turned-Giants farmhand Holub is Grant Kipp, whom Chicago might trade in a similar deal. Their targets in such moves will be similar to Walker, too: optionable arms and versatile position players. Ideally, the team would leave themselves some space on the roster, because they'll need to add multiple players via free agency and trades. However, they also have several players already on their 40-man who wouldn't be missed much if they were jettisoned. Ethan Roberts, Tyler Ferguson, Gavin Hollowell and infielder Gabriel Arias are all out of options, and when locked into the roster, all four have very little value. Arias is also arbitration-eligible, and could be non-tendered Friday even if he's not gone before then. Justin Dean, BJ Murray Jr., James Triantos, Jordan Wicks and Jayden Murray all have options remaining, but even that doesn't make any of them hard to lose, if needed. The Cubs have about a day and a half to capitalize on having plenty of room on their roster, when everyone else has very little. They're likely to make at least one trade before Tuesday's deadline. They might also waive reliever Eric Orze, another out-of-options arm, whom they picked up on waivers from the Twins earlier this month. If they can sneak Orze through, they could outright him to the minors and he would not have the right to elect free agency, so they'd effectively gain an option on him at the front end of next year. With barely 25 players on their 40-man roster who can actively help them reach the playoffs, the Cubs have heavy lifting ahead of them. There's far less time to do that than they would usually have, but they do have options. As he tries to fish in the many rivers of talent acquisition, Jed Hoyer will be active this week. How successful he is with all that activity will determine whether Chicago enters the lockout in position to make the playoffs in 2027 or not.- 1 comment
-
- jaxon wiggins
- grant kipp
- (and 8 more)
-
As what figures to be a very busy week throughout baseball gets underway, the Cubs enjoy a minor but meaningful advantage. They have 34 players on their 40-man roster right now, while much of the league faces a more acute roster crunch. The Red Sox, Tigers, Athletics, Mets and Nationals all have full 40-man lists. The White Sox, Astros, Mariners, Giants, Cardinals and Rays are all at 39. When the offseason begins, players slough off rosters and into free agency, so most teams have at least a modicum of breathing room. In mid-November, though, the squeeze begins anew. By 5 PM CT Tuesday, teams must add any eligible minor leaguers not currently on their 40-man rosters to those lists to shield them from the Rule 5 Draft. Players who have completed at least (depending on their age when they entered pro ball) four or five professional seasons are eligible for the draft if not added to the 40-man. This year, there's a twist, because the Rule 5 Draft usually takes place at the end of the annual Winter Meetings. Those are expected to be canceled this year, as the league embarks on what figures to be a prolonged lockout. Last time there was an offseason lockout, in 2021 and 2022, the Rule 5 Draft was ultimately canceled. However, teams aren't planning on getting that reprieve again, according to multiple executives. That's why, for instance, the Giants and Brewers got together on a trade Sunday evening, sending right-handed reliever Ryan Walker to Milwaukee in exchange for two pitching prospects. One of those prospects is Blake Holub, whom the Brewers would have had to add to their 40-man roster to protect. As mentioned above, the Giants face a 40-man crunch, and it's not yet clear whether Holub will fit onto their roster. By moving Walker off that roster, though, they created a much-needed vacancy. There will be several more moves like that one throughout the league this week. As one of the teams with ample room on the 40-man (for now), Chicago is already active in discussions with teams who are feeling their crunch, league sources said Sunday night. That's not to suggest that they don't face a crunch of their own. The Cubs have to add Jaxon Wiggins to their 40-man roster to protect him from the draft, and although Wiggins had a dreadful 2026 and looks like a reliever-only prospect with major health questions, he still has a ceiling as a high-octane, high-leverage arm. Chicago will protect that upside. They're also almost certain to protect Jose Escobar, 22, a Venezuelan second baseman and outfielder who has only reached High-A South Bend but performed well there and could be on a fast track to the majors from here. After that, the decisions get tougher, but there are several of them. Injuries have left big questions about the utility of Triple-A starters Brody McCullough, Will Sanders and Brandon Birdsell, but for a team starved for pitching depth, leaving (especially) McCullough exposed would be uncomfortable. They might add McCullough, too, which would push the roster to 37 players. Sanders, Birdsell and outfielders Carter Trice and Alexey Lumpuy all are candidates to be traded to teams more likely to protect them, though none are likely to be taken even if left vulnerable to it. The closest comp the Cubs have to Brewers-turned-Giants farmhand Holub is Grant Kipp, whom Chicago might trade in a similar deal. Their targets in such moves will be similar to Walker, too: optionable arms and versatile position players. Ideally, the team would leave themselves some space on the roster, because they'll need to add multiple players via free agency and trades. However, they also have several players already on their 40-man who wouldn't be missed much if they were jettisoned. Ethan Roberts, Tyler Ferguson, Gavin Hollowell and infielder Gabriel Arias are all out of options, and when locked into the roster, all four have very little value. Arias is also arbitration-eligible, and could be non-tendered Friday even if he's not gone before then. Justin Dean, BJ Murray Jr., James Triantos, Jordan Wicks and Jayden Murray all have options remaining, but even that doesn't make any of them hard to lose, if needed. The Cubs have about a day and a half to capitalize on having plenty of room on their roster, when everyone else has very little. They're likely to make at least one trade before Tuesday's deadline. They might also waive reliever Eric Orze, another out-of-options arm, whom they picked up on waivers from the Twins earlier this month. If they can sneak Orze through, they could outright him to the minors and he would not have the right to elect free agency, so they'd effectively gain an option on him at the front end of next year. With barely 25 players on their 40-man roster who can actively help them reach the playoffs, the Cubs have heavy lifting ahead of them. There's far less time to do that than they would usually have, but they do have options. As he tries to fish in the many rivers of talent acquisition, Jed Hoyer will be active this week. How successful he is with all that activity will determine whether Chicago enters the lockout in position to make the playoffs in 2027 or not. Image courtesy of David Banks-Imagn Images View full article
- 1 reply
-
- jaxon wiggins
- grant kipp
- (and 8 more)
-
As the Texas Rangers attempt an on-the-run reset whereby they would shed some of their more onerous contracts while remaining competitive in the wide-open AL West, they and the Cubs spoke this week about three starting pitchers who could offer partial solutions to the Cubs' glaring shortcomings in the rotation, sources familiar with the talks said. Jacob deGrom, Nathan Eovaldi and MacKenzie Gore (each of whom the Cubs have had some measure of interest in in the past) come with sticking points, but each also offers upside that would fill a key need for the North Siders. It's Now Officially Nathan Eovaldi Trade Season On Sunday, the Rangers will pay Eovaldi, 36, the first half of the $12-million signing bonus he received when he re-signed with the team in late 2024. In effect, that opens up the market for the veteran righthander, one source said. The structure of Eovaldi's deal is unusual. He signed for $75 million over three years, the last of which will be the 2027 campaign. However, his bonus became a de facto form of backloading for the deal, as $6 million was made payable on Nov. 15, 2026, and another $6 million is due in early 2028, after the end of the contract. That doesn't affect the competitive-balance tax (CBT) number assigned to the deal for each of the three seasons—$25 million apiece—but it did complicate initial trade conversations this month. The Rangers, trying to stay competitive but also on budget, would have liked to move Eovaldi with all $32 million still owed to him, in a perfect world. They were unwilling to deal him for the returns they were offered at that price, though. Now that his actual price is down to $26 million, a trade is a bit more plausible. Although not as hard a thrower as he was half a decade ago, Eovaldi is still a force to be reckoned with, and even with a substantial price tag on a one-year engagement, he'd come with plenty of surplus value. His arsenal includes five solid offerings and multiple ways to get whiffs against both lefties and righties. He fills up the zone and still works deep into games when he's going well; he pitched at least seven innings nine times in 2026. However, Eovaldi's 2025 season (in which he'd been making a bid for a surprising Cy Young Award) was cut short by shoulder trouble, and his 2026 campaign was interrupted by a balky elbow. He finished the season healthy, but given his age and that track record, there's some reason for pause. (He also saw his home-run rate tick up.) Eovaldi also must approve any move; his deal includes a full no-trade clause. One source said the pitcher has had interest in pitching for the Cubs in the past and could be open to the move, but it's not clear whether Texas has yet established which teams he'd accede to be dealt to. With the bonus payment out of the way, at least that can be the biggest contractual question hanging over a potential deal. The Immovable Object: Jacob deGrom The Cubs were also in touch with Texas before the trade deadline this August, when the Rangers made a late pivot and considered selling. However, it was the team from near Atlanta that came near acquiring deGrom, before he thwarted the transaction via his own no-trade protection. He's expected to be at least somewhat more open to a move this winter, but even if that's true, he'll have the luxury of deciding where he's willing to go. Understandably, Cubs personnel checked in to see what the asking price would be for the expensive two-time Cy Young Award winner, in case he could be persuaded to join them. he'll turn 39 next June, but deGrom has a lowish number on his arm's odometer, having been a position player until college. He's made 61 starts over the last two seasons, racking up 386 strikeouts in 335 1/3 innings and running a solid 3.57 ERA. The stuff is still nasty; that strikeout total is more than 28% of all the batters he's faced since the start of 2025. Assuming deGrom would give his assent, the Cubs would be getting a frontline starter with the potential to start Game 1 of a playoff series. He won't come cheap, in that he's owed $37 million for 2027—which is also the annual average value (AAV) of his contract and (therefore) his CBT number. However, a $20-million club option will be tacked on to the end of his deal because of the Tommy John surgery that sidelined him for much of 2023 and 2024, which would soften the blow to Chicago's budget and give them a second season of control over him if they want it. For all of those reasons, deGrom would cost some real prospect capital, which is in short supply for the Cubs. A deal for him is viewed as least likely of the three Rangers hurlers on the block, but as an alternative to spending a similar annual figure over a much longer term for Tarik Skubal, the Cubs might view deGrom as an alluring option. MacKenzie Gore: The White Whale The Cubs have long admired lefthander MacKenzie Gore. They talked to the Nationals about him before the 2025 trade deadline and again last winter, but never liked the steep asking price to which Washington cleaved. They also didn't think much of the pitch mix or mechanical changes Gore made in 2026, after being dealt to the Rangers. However, Gore did make one important kind of progress this season, starting 34 games and pitching a career-high 173 innings for Texas. Perhaps the time will finally be right for Chicago to reel in their big fish. Gore is under control for just one more season, so the price tag is coming down, and his performance was not as far worse than in the past as his topline results were. He'll be paid roughly $9 million in his final year of arbitration eligibility. The Rangers would rather trade deGrom or Eovaldi, if all else were equal, but they have the same problem the Cubs do in any potential pursuit of those hurlers: their contracts, and the questions about each player's age and utility beyond 2027. Gore would cost the best prospect package, but he could also be made the qualifying offer (assuming that still exists in the new collective bargaining agreement) after 2027. Unlike deGrom and Eovaldi, he has no way to block a trade, and he's a serious candidate for an extension if the team believes in him enough and has productive early conversations after acquiring him. Trading for him would leave more room in the budget for free-agent splurges than would landing either Eovaldi or deGrom. If the Cubs do get Gore, it could come on the other side of the looming lockout, once a decision on the future of the QO has been reached. That would bring clarity to his market. The Cubs need to make some pitching additions before the work stoppage, though, so Eovaldi and deGrom could suit their timeline better. By no means was this the only (or even the primary) avenue the Cubs explored as they sought pitching help this week. They were very active in discussions with representatives for several free-agent starters, sources said, including 2026 trade acquisition David Peterson, Japanese fireballer Kaima Taira and Michael Soroka. Though his tenure with the Cubs in 2025 was marred by injury and viewed as a flop by most fans, Soroka enjoyed working with Cubs pitching guru Tyler Zombro, one person noted, and could circle back to the team as a second-tier addition this offseason. A team source acknowledged that Chicago can't fill their needs in the rotation purely through free agency. It would be too expensive, particularly because it would probably saddle them with multiple deals that stretch past the end of this decade. Instead, they'll try to both sign and trade for pitching help, and the Rangers are one team they know to be open to deals. Their discussions in Las Vegas didn't yield any immediate progress, but the sides might well be back in touch soon. Image courtesy of Jerome Miron-Imagn Images View full article
- 2 replies
-
- jacob degrom
- nathan eovaldi
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
As the Texas Rangers attempt an on-the-run reset whereby they would shed some of their more onerous contracts while remaining competitive in the wide-open AL West, they and the Cubs spoke this week about three starting pitchers who could offer partial solutions to the Cubs' glaring shortcomings in the rotation, sources familiar with the talks said. Jacob deGrom, Nathan Eovaldi and MacKenzie Gore (each of whom the Cubs have had some measure of interest in in the past) come with sticking points, but each also offers upside that would fill a key need for the North Siders. It's Now Officially Nathan Eovaldi Trade Season On Sunday, the Rangers will pay Eovaldi, 36, the first half of the $12-million signing bonus he received when he re-signed with the team in late 2024. In effect, that opens up the market for the veteran righthander, one source said. The structure of Eovaldi's deal is unusual. He signed for $75 million over three years, the last of which will be the 2027 campaign. However, his bonus became a de facto form of backloading for the deal, as $6 million was made payable on Nov. 15, 2026, and another $6 million is due in early 2028, after the end of the contract. That doesn't affect the competitive-balance tax (CBT) number assigned to the deal for each of the three seasons—$25 million apiece—but it did complicate initial trade conversations this month. The Rangers, trying to stay competitive but also on budget, would have liked to move Eovaldi with all $32 million still owed to him, in a perfect world. They were unwilling to deal him for the returns they were offered at that price, though. Now that his actual price is down to $26 million, a trade is a bit more plausible. Although not as hard a thrower as he was half a decade ago, Eovaldi is still a force to be reckoned with, and even with a substantial price tag on a one-year engagement, he'd come with plenty of surplus value. His arsenal includes five solid offerings and multiple ways to get whiffs against both lefties and righties. He fills up the zone and still works deep into games when he's going well; he pitched at least seven innings nine times in 2026. However, Eovaldi's 2025 season (in which he'd been making a bid for a surprising Cy Young Award) was cut short by shoulder trouble, and his 2026 campaign was interrupted by a balky elbow. He finished the season healthy, but given his age and that track record, there's some reason for pause. (He also saw his home-run rate tick up.) Eovaldi also must approve any move; his deal includes a full no-trade clause. One source said the pitcher has had interest in pitching for the Cubs in the past and could be open to the move, but it's not clear whether Texas has yet established which teams he'd accede to be dealt to. With the bonus payment out of the way, at least that can be the biggest contractual question hanging over a potential deal. The Immovable Object: Jacob deGrom The Cubs were also in touch with Texas before the trade deadline this August, when the Rangers made a late pivot and considered selling. However, it was the team from near Atlanta that came near acquiring deGrom, before he thwarted the transaction via his own no-trade protection. He's expected to be at least somewhat more open to a move this winter, but even if that's true, he'll have the luxury of deciding where he's willing to go. Understandably, Cubs personnel checked in to see what the asking price would be for the expensive two-time Cy Young Award winner, in case he could be persuaded to join them. he'll turn 39 next June, but deGrom has a lowish number on his arm's odometer, having been a position player until college. He's made 61 starts over the last two seasons, racking up 386 strikeouts in 335 1/3 innings and running a solid 3.57 ERA. The stuff is still nasty; that strikeout total is more than 28% of all the batters he's faced since the start of 2025. Assuming deGrom would give his assent, the Cubs would be getting a frontline starter with the potential to start Game 1 of a playoff series. He won't come cheap, in that he's owed $37 million for 2027—which is also the annual average value (AAV) of his contract and (therefore) his CBT number. However, a $20-million club option will be tacked on to the end of his deal because of the Tommy John surgery that sidelined him for much of 2023 and 2024, which would soften the blow to Chicago's budget and give them a second season of control over him if they want it. For all of those reasons, deGrom would cost some real prospect capital, which is in short supply for the Cubs. A deal for him is viewed as least likely of the three Rangers hurlers on the block, but as an alternative to spending a similar annual figure over a much longer term for Tarik Skubal, the Cubs might view deGrom as an alluring option. MacKenzie Gore: The White Whale The Cubs have long admired lefthander MacKenzie Gore. They talked to the Nationals about him before the 2025 trade deadline and again last winter, but never liked the steep asking price to which Washington cleaved. They also didn't think much of the pitch mix or mechanical changes Gore made in 2026, after being dealt to the Rangers. However, Gore did make one important kind of progress this season, starting 34 games and pitching a career-high 173 innings for Texas. Perhaps the time will finally be right for Chicago to reel in their big fish. Gore is under control for just one more season, so the price tag is coming down, and his performance was not as far worse than in the past as his topline results were. He'll be paid roughly $9 million in his final year of arbitration eligibility. The Rangers would rather trade deGrom or Eovaldi, if all else were equal, but they have the same problem the Cubs do in any potential pursuit of those hurlers: their contracts, and the questions about each player's age and utility beyond 2027. Gore would cost the best prospect package, but he could also be made the qualifying offer (assuming that still exists in the new collective bargaining agreement) after 2027. Unlike deGrom and Eovaldi, he has no way to block a trade, and he's a serious candidate for an extension if the team believes in him enough and has productive early conversations after acquiring him. Trading for him would leave more room in the budget for free-agent splurges than would landing either Eovaldi or deGrom. If the Cubs do get Gore, it could come on the other side of the looming lockout, once a decision on the future of the QO has been reached. That would bring clarity to his market. The Cubs need to make some pitching additions before the work stoppage, though, so Eovaldi and deGrom could suit their timeline better. By no means was this the only (or even the primary) avenue the Cubs explored as they sought pitching help this week. They were very active in discussions with representatives for several free-agent starters, sources said, including 2026 trade acquisition David Peterson, Japanese fireballer Kaima Taira and Michael Soroka. Though his tenure with the Cubs in 2025 was marred by injury and viewed as a flop by most fans, Soroka enjoyed working with Cubs pitching guru Tyler Zombro, one person noted, and could circle back to the team as a second-tier addition this offseason. A team source acknowledged that Chicago can't fill their needs in the rotation purely through free agency. It would be too expensive, particularly because it would probably saddle them with multiple deals that stretch past the end of this decade. Instead, they'll try to both sign and trade for pitching help, and the Rangers are one team they know to be open to deals. Their discussions in Las Vegas didn't yield any immediate progress, but the sides might well be back in touch soon.
- 2 comments
-
- jacob degrom
- nathan eovaldi
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
"No one, it becomes clear, can conquer this impossible and unpredictable game," Roger Angell once wrote of baseball. "Yet every player tries, and now and again—very rarely—we see a man who seems to have met all the demands, challenged all the implacable averages, spurned the mere luck. He has defied baseball, even altered it, and for a time at least the game is truly his." That's the kind of season Pete Crow-Armstrong had in 2026. He ensorcelled a game that bedevils even its greatest practitioners. He broke the mustang that is baseball until it settled into a companionable canter at his side. For as long as any player since the full professionalization and integration of the game has ever done so, he simply seemed to have the game solved. Like a streak, he shot across the outfield, mocking the men who have tried and failed to build truly deterrent systems for intercepting ballistic missiles by making that job look fairly trivial, with a target much smaller than a missile and no computer more advanced than his brain. At the plate, he slashed through the ball with a ferocity just controlled enough to direct much of the resulting contact to the pull field, where he found plenty of bleacher seats and plenty of gaps in the opponents' defense. His dramatic improvement in plate discipline rounded him out as an offensive weapon, making him one of the top hitters in the league. Once he reached base, he made the game look even more solved. His reads were brilliant. His slides were angry. He forced mistakes and exulted in each base they gained him. No one was safe. Brewers closer Trevor Megill gave up only one home run all year; it was to Crow-Armstrong. Cy Young Award winner Jacob Misiorowski only allowed one contested straight steal; it was to Crow-Armstrong. He finished with 45 homers and 41 steals. He became the fourth player ever to amass 80 or more extra-base hits, 80 or more walks and 40 or more stolen bases in one campaign, joining Carlos Beltrán (2004), Ronald Acuña Jr. (2023), and Shohei Ohtani (2024). He also became the avatar of the Cubs. It was a non-stop show. His speed, power and passion made him loom larger over every game than any player in recent memory. Even Ohtani only had one offensive season to match this one, and it came in one of the years when he didn't pitch (or, therefore, provide any defensive value). Without Crow-Armstrong, the Cubs would have scarcely been a winning team, let alone a playoff qualifier. They weren't bad, but they were only good because of him. That he so transcended the game in the lead-in season for a six-year deal that now ranks among the most team-friendly in baseball (before it even begins) is just gravy. Though the Cubs didn't achieve what they aspired to this season, Crow-Armstrong made it the most memorable Chicago season since 2016, and one of the five most thrilling of the last 30 years. He altered baseball, and seized it. The game is wily; it's slippery. Even Crow-Armstrong will probably never own it quite the way he did this year ever again. That only makes it more important to savor the way he did so for a long, brilliant summer. Since the end of the season, Crow-Armstrong has won Sports Info Solutions's Defensive Player of the Year Award, a Gold Glove in center field, a Platinum Glove, and the National League Hank Aaron Award. This culminating honor completes a collection of of them that will be hard for any player to match. It also means a $2.5-million windfall for Crow-Armstrong, via the new pre-arbitration bonus pool system. He's made an enormous amount of money this season, even if most of it is in endorsements and future earnings, even after gaining this bonus. The fans he's made (and made smile) are an even more hard-won reward, though. Image courtesy of David Banks-Imagn Images View full article
-
Coronation: Pete Crow-Armstrong Wins 2026 National League MVP Award
Matthew Trueblood posted an article in Cubs
"No one, it becomes clear, can conquer this impossible and unpredictable game," Roger Angell once wrote of baseball. "Yet every player tries, and now and again—very rarely—we see a man who seems to have met all the demands, challenged all the implacable averages, spurned the mere luck. He has defied baseball, even altered it, and for a time at least the game is truly his." That's the kind of season Pete Crow-Armstrong had in 2026. He ensorcelled a game that bedevils even its greatest practitioners. He broke the mustang that is baseball until it settled into a companionable canter at his side. For as long as any player since the full professionalization and integration of the game has ever done so, he simply seemed to have the game solved. Like a streak, he shot across the outfield, mocking the men who have tried and failed to build truly deterrent systems for intercepting ballistic missiles by making that job look fairly trivial, with a target much smaller than a missile and no computer more advanced than his brain. At the plate, he slashed through the ball with a ferocity just controlled enough to direct much of the resulting contact to the pull field, where he found plenty of bleacher seats and plenty of gaps in the opponents' defense. His dramatic improvement in plate discipline rounded him out as an offensive weapon, making him one of the top hitters in the league. Once he reached base, he made the game look even more solved. His reads were brilliant. His slides were angry. He forced mistakes and exulted in each base they gained him. No one was safe. Brewers closer Trevor Megill gave up only one home run all year; it was to Crow-Armstrong. Cy Young Award winner Jacob Misiorowski only allowed one contested straight steal; it was to Crow-Armstrong. He finished with 45 homers and 41 steals. He became the fourth player ever to amass 80 or more extra-base hits, 80 or more walks and 40 or more stolen bases in one campaign, joining Carlos Beltrán (2004), Ronald Acuña Jr. (2023), and Shohei Ohtani (2024). He also became the avatar of the Cubs. It was a non-stop show. His speed, power and passion made him loom larger over every game than any player in recent memory. Even Ohtani only had one offensive season to match this one, and it came in one of the years when he didn't pitch (or, therefore, provide any defensive value). Without Crow-Armstrong, the Cubs would have scarcely been a winning team, let alone a playoff qualifier. They weren't bad, but they were only good because of him. That he so transcended the game in the lead-in season for a six-year deal that now ranks among the most team-friendly in baseball (before it even begins) is just gravy. Though the Cubs didn't achieve what they aspired to this season, Crow-Armstrong made it the most memorable Chicago season since 2016, and one of the five most thrilling of the last 30 years. He altered baseball, and seized it. The game is wily; it's slippery. Even Crow-Armstrong will probably never own it quite the way he did this year ever again. That only makes it more important to savor the way he did so for a long, brilliant summer. Since the end of the season, Crow-Armstrong has won Sports Info Solutions's Defensive Player of the Year Award, a Gold Glove in center field, a Platinum Glove, and the National League Hank Aaron Award. This culminating honor completes a collection of of them that will be hard for any player to match. It also means a $2.5-million windfall for Crow-Armstrong, via the new pre-arbitration bonus pool system. He's made an enormous amount of money this season, even if most of it is in endorsements and future earnings, even after gaining this bonus. The fans he's made (and made smile) are an even more hard-won reward, though. -
I wouldn't bet on four north of the Linea Rea. I think they just think they can get another Rea-caliber guy much cheaper. If I'm guessing, I think they're aiming for one from the set of Peralta, Rogers, King, Gray and Taira and two from a lower tier that includes both Dustin May and Peterson, as well as Boyd, Griffin, Mize, a bunch of trade candidates. Then someone cheap to absorb innings, like Civale and Rea have in recent years.
- 2 replies
-
- edward cabrera
- javier assad
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
The Cubs will leave Las Vegas this week without having added a notable pitcher to their projected 2027 staff, but plenty of information gathered this week nonetheless brought their offseason roadmap into focus. First, Ben Brown underwent neck surgery Monday, which the team hopes will finally stabilize the nagging stress reaction that has hampered his attempts to establish himself in the majors. However, the path back to a big-league mound looks like a long one, so scratch Brown off any list of candidates to open the season in the starting rotation. With Brown out of the mix (at least initially) and Cade Horton unlikely to get back into big-league action until at least June, that rotation looks wide-open for any of several pitchers who ended the year in limbo for the team. When GM Carter Hawkins met the media Tuesday, he had chances to name Edward Cabrera, Braxton Garrett and/or Javier Assad as claimants to multiple openings. Instead, he seemed to lump them into an unexpected competition. Cubs still "figuring out how to get outs" with Edward Cabrera Hawkins praised Cabrera's raw talent and his attitude. Though injuries (including recurring blister issues and a major leg injury) disrupted his season so much that he was unable to enmesh himself much in the clubhouse, the Cubs GM called him "great teammate [and] a guy that really cares". However, the team seemed frustrated with his inability to stay on the mound at multiple points during the season. On Tuesday, Hawkins talked about both strategizing with Cabrera to toughen the skin on his fingers to minimize the risk of blisters and keeping "on top of it" with him via unusually active communication to ensure he's in shape to pitch. Cabrera is still in Chicago, as pitching coach Tommy Hottovy and members of the front office check in with him daily. Late in the season, the team moved Cabrera to the bullpen—a failed experiment, but one they felt was necessary. Hawkins acknowledged that it wasn't an easy conversation, despite Cabrera's eagerness to help the team, but stopped short of saying that he would be guaranteed a starting role to begin 2027. "I’m glad he knows we have his back. We do have his back," Hawkins told reporters. "We also got to get some talent out of him. Got to get some outs out of him." Though the team loved the upside they saw in him and paid a handsome prospect price to acquire him, they now admit to some major uncertainty about how best to use him, or what to expect. "So our focus is going to be more on figuring out how to get outs with him, and then you know, whether he’s happy or not," Hawkins said. That's a jarring statement, coming from a top decision-maker for a team who just dealt for the player one injury-plagued season ago. Cabrera surely has a leg up on a rotation spot for 2027, but it's clear that he'll have to earn it. Chicago "jerked around" Javier Assad in 2026, and they might do it again. Unlike Cabrera, Assad seems to have the privilege of heading into this offseason as a projected starter—but there's a crucial caveat. Hawkins said the team will bring Assad to camp as a starter, but that might turn out to be more about flexibility than about finally giving him a long runway. "The amount of innings relative to just how much the fan base really embraced Javy was really interesting," he said. "You just don’t see guys that throw that little be loved that much, which is a testament to him and his attitude. We jerked him around a decent amount last year, and he didn’t like us that much. But he loved his teammates, and he loved helping the Cubs win." That's a second acknowledgement of frustration from individual pitchers toward the team late last year, and it's hard to blame Assad for feeling that way. He's been yo-yoed between the majors and minors about as much as one can imagine, but miraculously (for the Cubs; Assad would give a different descriptor), he can still be optioned to the minors in 2027. That jerking around Hawkins mentioned left him five days shy of four full years of big-league service, so his free agency is still three seasons away. He wasn't a Super Two player, but he could end up going through arbitration four times. He could also be stashed in the minors at various points this season, to make the most of the team's depth. That, as much as anything, is why Hawkins tabbed him as a clear starter for next year. If the team decides he's not a starter worth a rotation spot, they can keep him stretched out but use him in the minors instead. It's not fair to Assad, but it's how things are. Hawkins said Assad is "going to be counted on for valuable innings again next year," but that conspicuously avoids committing either to those innings coming in the rotation or to him being in the majors the whole time. Cubs will do what they can to keep Braxton Garrett, but that might mean a move to bullpen. Unlike Assad (but like Cabrera), Braxton Garrett can't be sent to the minors without being exposed to the other 29 teams via the waiver process. Therefore, the team will do whatever they can to ensure that he's on the roster come Opening Day. "The expectation will be that he comes in and is competing for a rotation spot," Hawkins said. "He’ll be out of options, so he’ll need to make our club. Expecting to make our club, and if that’s not in the rotation," then the team would explore fitting him in as a reliever, instead. Assuming Garrett does stick around, he's under team control through 2028. That gives the team added incentive to hold onto him. Holding onto him, though, means being open to putting him in the bullpen. This is part of why they kept Garrett in the minors until the tail end of the season—to maximize his starts at Triple-A Iowa and give him ample opportunities to develop into the pitcher they hope he'll be. Uncertainty Makes Clear Why Chicago Will Splurge on Starters It's not good news, for the players or the organization, that Cabrera, Assad and Garrett are only viewed as tenuous rotation candidates, even by the team itself. Hawkins's remarks this week were telling. It's clear that the team won't reserve even two rotation spots for these three pitchers, let alone three. It's possible two (or all three) do make the rotation, but that won't be how the team approaches their plan for this offseason. Once you understand that, many things fall into place. The only pitcher with a reasonably firm grip on a rotation spot for the 2027 Cubs, right now, is Justin Steele—who comes with many question marks, himself. In light of that fact, you can understand why the team isn't in on Tarik Skubal. You can understand, too, why they're out on Adrian Morejon and David Bednar. You can even see why they won't be bringing back Seiya Suzuki, signing Randy Arozarena, or winning any especially robust bidding war for Teruaki Sato. Those individuals would each take up too great a share of the resources available to the team, given their own understanding of their needs. You and I are free to disagree with the team about where its budget should be, but the front office has to work within the budget they've been handed, and it's pretty clear that that budget won't permit them to acquire three solid starting pitchers and address their positional needs with any of the top-of-the-market free agents in the mix. Skubal will get $40 million a year, or very near that number. Bednar and Morejon are more likely to settle around $20 million a year, but they'll each also pitch less than half as much as Skubal. Maybe the best way to see it is this: Clearly, the Cubs feel they need to fill at least 400 reliable starter innings for 2026. They might have $100 million to spend, in total. They might have a little less. Either way, 180 innings of Skubal at $40 million leaves just $60 million to fill the other 220, plus at least one corner outfielder, a catcher, and any help in the bullpen. Bednar or Morejon would leave them with $80 million to spend and no progress made toward that 400-inning goal. Arozarena, Sato or Suzuki would pose the same problem. Because they don't feel they can write Assad, Brown, Cabrera, Garrett or Horton into the rotation in permanent ink, the team needs to fill a huge hole in a pitching staff they're striving to make playoff-caliber. They have financial flexibility to do so, but they have to do it in a more diffuse way than fans (who always love big names more than the Cubs front office does, anyway) would prefer. Hawkins's remarks about three back-end candidates Tuesday make that clear. The biggest problem might be Tom Ricketts's refusal to spend at the level he should, but since that obstacle is immovable for the time being (and since they've failed to either get the best out of various hurlers or keep them healthy), the front office is taking a starless tack as they face a murky winter.
- 2 comments
-
- edward cabrera
- javier assad
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:

