Calvin Johnson for MJD?

[Butterscup1679666578]

Would you trade Calvin Johnson straight up for MJD? 12 team league. No PPR.

 

Starting RBs are Frank Gore and Marshawn Lynch

My other starting WR is Larry Fitzgerald. Have Demaryius Thomas in the flex.

 

Have Benson, Gerhart, Garcon, Denarius Moore on the bench.

[Guest]

I would not trade Megatron, no matter the cost.

[Butterscup1679666578]

That's kind of what I'm thinking. I'm trying to push a 2-for-2 involving Fitz and one of my RBs for MJD and someone else (Maclin?) but I don't know if he'll bite. I'd love to move one of my WRs for a top QB since I'm starting RG3 but I hate my depth at RB as well.

[rawaction]

No. If u wouldnt draft MJD over Megatron dont trade for him now. Plus there is a bad track record for holdouts getting hurt or underperforming.

[Butterscup1679666578]

He just threw Fitz/Lynch for MJD/Maclin at me. I don't love Lynch at all, but raw's point on holdouts is true as well.

[rawaction]

I actually like Lynch in non ppr. I wouldnt do that either. HEs likely to produce similar to MJD this year. At least closer to mjd than Maclin will be to Fitz.

 

The guy i really dislike for u is Gore

[SouthSideRyan]

No you idiot

[Pushfrog98]

If I'm the one with MJD, yes. I trade straight up for Megatron.

[Smack]

I agree with everyone above. Megatron > MJD

[Banedon]

MJD is gonna be a 3rd down back to start the season because he's not in shape enough to be an every down back. Megatron ftw.

[Butterscup1679666578]

Yeah, I got him off Megatron for MJD and we started talking a package deal with Fitz involved but it fell through. I'm going to start the year with the team I got and adjust in a few weeks if needed.