How dumb would I be for not taking this trade?

[UMFan83]

I give up:

Josh Hamilton, OF

Scott Shields, Disabled MR guy

 

I get:

Jason Bay, OF

Aaron Rowand, OF

A.J. Burnett, Soon-to-be Disabled SP guy

 

Not that it matters much, but Holds matter in this league.

[MADD_DOG_31]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

[jyoung55]

I don't like Rowand or Burnett. Can you get someone else to fill their slots with still doing using Bay and Hamilton/Shields as the base?

[Post Count Padder]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

[nilodnayr]

I give up:

Josh Hamilton, OF

Scott Shields, Disabled MR guy

 

I get:

Jason Bay, OF

Aaron Rowand, OF

A.J. Burnett, Soon-to-be Disabled SP guy

 

Not that it matters much, but Holds matter in this league.

 

It wouldn't be a horrible idea to sell high on Hamilton to eliminate risk and get some certainty, but obviously Bay, Rowand, and Burnett accomplish neither. Shields is probably done as having value even in a league that counts holds, hes simply been way too overworked.

 

Hamilton and Shields are both good guys to deal, but Bay, Rowand (hello replacement level), and Burnett are the opposite of the type of players you'd want.

[Vanilla Ice]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

[anabiono]

since hamilton is going to absolutely rake this year...no...don't do it

 

rowand doesn't play in philly anymore

[Post Count Padder]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

[Vanilla Ice]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

 

FINE

[Post Count Padder]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

 

FINE

BE LIKE THAT

[17 Seconds]

I'd keep Hamilton.

[Vanilla Ice]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

FINE

BE LIKE THAT

I WILL

[Post Count Padder]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

FINE

BE LIKE THAT

I WILL

IF YOU SAY SO

[Derwood]

http://www.goodexperience.com/broken/i/04/02/capslock-s.jpg

[Vanilla Ice]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

FINE

BE LIKE THAT

I WILL

IF YOU SAY SO

GOOD

[Post Count Padder]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

FINE

BE LIKE THAT

I WILL

IF YOU SAY SO

GOOD

GREAT

[Vanilla Ice]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

FINE

BE LIKE THAT

I WILL

IF YOU SAY SO

GOOD

GREAT

LEGENDARY

[Post Count Padder]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

FINE

BE LIKE THAT

I WILL

IF YOU SAY SO

GOOD

GREAT

LEGENDARY

EPIC

[Vanilla Ice]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

FINE

BE LIKE THAT

I WILL

IF YOU SAY SO

GOOD

GREAT

LEGENDARY

EPIC

COLOSSAL

[Post Count Padder]

ID RATHER HAVE HAMILTON AND SHIELDS IF YOU SAY HOLDS COUNT....SHIELDS WILL PROBABLY END UP WITH MORE WINS THAN BURNETT TOO

LOUD NOISES

CAPS LOCK

OK

FINE

BE LIKE THAT

I WILL

IF YOU SAY SO

GOOD

GREAT

LEGENDARY

EPIC

COLOSSAL

GEOVANY SOTO

[TruffleShuffle]

http://maddox.xmission.com/keyboard4.jpg

[Post Count Padder]

http://maddox.xmission.com/keyboard4.jpg

I'LL TAKE IT INTO CONSIDERATION

[Vanilla Ice]

http://maddox.xmission.com/keyboard4.jpg

I'LL TAKE IT INTO CONSIDERATION

 

I WONT

[Post Count Padder]

http://maddox.xmission.com/keyboard4.jpg

I'LL TAKE IT INTO CONSIDERATION

 

I WONT

ok

[NCCubFan]

OK, this thread has obviously become worthless.