My annual "rate my fantasy baseball team" thread

[Post Count Padder]

I'm in two leagues this year. First team is 12 team league and second team is 10 team league. First team:

 

c- GEOVANY SOTO

1b- Nick Swisher

2b- Orlando Hudson

ss- Hanley Ramirez

3b- A-Ram

OF- Carlos Beltran, Hunter Pence, Pat Burrell

Util- Ryan Garko, Jeremy Hermida

Bench- Michael Bourn, Asdrubal Cabrera, Billy Butler, Mike Napoli

 

SP- Big Z, Chris Young

RP- Huston Street, Matt Capps

P- Rich Hill, Jered Weaver, Matt Garza

Bench- Gil Meche, Kerry Wood

 

 

League 2:

 

c- GEOVANY SOTO

1b- Prince Fielder

2b- BJ Upton

ss- Miguel Tejada

3b- A-Ram

of- Carlos Lee, Adam Dunn, Nick Markakis

Util- Torii Hunter

Bench- Garko, Howie Kendrick, Jhonny Peralta, Johnny Damon

 

SP- Johan Santana, Javier Vazquez

RP- Takashi Saito, Chad Cordero

P- Kelvim Escobar, Pedro, Brad Penny

Bench- Oliver Perez

[sneakypower]

your first team is steals starved and I'm not too keen on your batting average either. Beltran went under the knife for both knees and scares me worse than Pujols. there's a better 2B than the O dog on somebody's bench or FA. i'd scour the waiver wire for better #5 starter. dustin mcgowan? derek lowe?

 

verdict: middle of the pack team

 

the second team- oh thats so much better. you've got too much power still, trade dunn for victorino and a closer and put pennys big ass on the bench or the FA pool. i don't trust him.

 

verdict: solid 2nd place team, first place contender if you could trade dunn for SV and say, raffy soriano

[JimSorgi]

your first team is steals starved and I'm not too keen on your batting average either. Beltran went under the knife for both knees and scares me worse than Pujols. there's a better 2B than the O dog on somebody's bench or FA. i'd scour the waiver wire for better #5 starter. dustin mcgowan? derek lowe?

 

verdict: middle of the pack team

 

the second team- oh thats so much better. you've got too much power still, trade dunn for victorino and a closer and put pennys big ass on the bench or the FA pool. i don't trust him.

 

verdict: solid 2nd place team, first place contender if you could trade dunn for SV and say, raffy soriano

What's wrong with Brad Penny?