M. Giles or Peralta

[ChiCubsFan]

Which has more trade value in a keeper league?

 

ON a related note...would you trade either of them for Murton, Hawpe, Bill Hall, Radhames Liz (prospect), Daiskuke Matsuzaka (prospect from Japan), and Gaby Sanchez (prospect)?

[SouthSideRyan]

Which has more trade value in a keeper league?

 

ON a related note...would you trade either of them for Murton, Hawpe, Bill Hall, Radhames Liz (prospect), Daiskuke Matsuzaka (prospect from Japan), and Gaby Sanchez (prospect)?

 

Well I drafted Peralta in the 2nd round, so I'd say him.

 

But then again I'm an idiot.

 

I'm confused on the trade. You'd be getting all 6 for Peralta or Giles?

[Mark_R]

Marcus Giles isn't really that good.

[nilodnayr]

Peralta is way more valuable.

[ChiCubsFan]

Which has more trade value in a keeper league?

 

ON a related note...would you trade either of them for Murton, Hawpe, Bill Hall, Radhames Liz (prospect), Daiskuke Matsuzaka (prospect from Japan), and Gaby Sanchez (prospect)?

 

Well I drafted Peralta in the 2nd round, so I'd say him.

 

But then again I'm an idiot.

 

I'm confused on the trade. You'd be getting all 6 for Peralta or Giles?

 

Yes. I'd have to give him back the 3 worst prospects of mine (Michael Constanzo, Carlos Marmol, and someone else) and I'm actually including Jesse Crain (who has sucked very bad this year and just decided to leave off). So basically it would be Crain, Giles/Peralta, and my three worst prospects for Hawpe, Bill Hall, Murton, and 3 pretty good prospects.

[ChiCubsFan]

Peralta is way more valuable.

 

I thought so, I was just worried about his slow start. I also have Stephen Drew in the minors. I guess I'll trade Giles and keep Peralta. I have TWalk anyways.

[nilodnayr]

Peralta is way more valuable.

 

I thought so, I was just worried about his slow start. I also have Stephen Drew in the minors. I guess I'll trade Giles and keep Peralta. I have TWalk anyways.

 

2b is a more offensive position, and even though his numbers last year look oustanding, consider the fact that he was platooning in the 9 hole for 1/3rd of the year!!! Anyone can struggle in 15 games. Take solace in the fact that hes still scoring runs and driving guys in. In that lineup, its hard not to at least put up some quality fantasy numbers.

[ChiCubsFan]

Well that previous trade fell through because he refused to include Hall unless I did it for Peralta instead of Giles and then he refused to include Sanchez and would only give me either Hawpe or Murton, and not both. But I have a new offer for Giles. I'm in need of a RF so he offered me Church, Bobby Jenks, a 2nd round prospect pick in next years draft, and Adam Lind (outfield prospect for the Blue Jays) OR David (?) Purey (pitching prospect for the Blue Jays) for Giles. I'm not really sure if I want to do it or not. I'm thinking to not do it, but I just wanted to get an opinion. Basically is Church and Jenks worht Giles? I don't think too much of either of the prospects (although Lind isn't too bad) or the 2nd round pick.

[Ding Dong Johnson]

Jhonny

[nilodnayr]

Well that previous trade fell through because he refused to include Hall unless I did it for Peralta instead of Giles and then he refused to include Sanchez and would only give me either Hawpe or Murton, and not both. But I have a new offer for Giles. I'm in need of a RF so he offered me Church, Bobby Jenks, a 2nd round prospect pick in next years draft, and Adam Lind (outfield prospect for the Blue Jays) OR David (?) Purey (pitching prospect for the Blue Jays) for Giles. I'm not really sure if I want to do it or not. I'm thinking to not do it, but I just wanted to get an opinion. Basically is Church and Jenks worht Giles? I don't think too much of either of the prospects (although Lind isn't too bad) or the 2nd round pick.

 

All depends as to whether you think Church is going to stay with the Nationals organization, or even to that point, what the management is going to be like under the new National's owner. Also, do you have specific OF positions, or is it just OF? Obviously with the latter, Church's value is diminished.

[ChiCubsFan]

Well that previous trade fell through because he refused to include Hall unless I did it for Peralta instead of Giles and then he refused to include Sanchez and would only give me either Hawpe or Murton, and not both. But I have a new offer for Giles. I'm in need of a RF so he offered me Church, Bobby Jenks, a 2nd round prospect pick in next years draft, and Adam Lind (outfield prospect for the Blue Jays) OR David (?) Purey (pitching prospect for the Blue Jays) for Giles. I'm not really sure if I want to do it or not. I'm thinking to not do it, but I just wanted to get an opinion. Basically is Church and Jenks worht Giles? I don't think too much of either of the prospects (although Lind isn't too bad) or the 2nd round pick.

 

All depends as to whether you think Church is going to stay with the Nationals organization, or even to that point, what the management is going to be like under the new National's owner. Also, do you have specific OF positions, or is it just OF? Obviously with the latter, Church's value is diminished.

 

Its specific positions. LF, CF, RF. My RFs right now are WM Pena and Hector Luna, so obviously I am in need of a RF. WM Pena could turn out to be my RF of the future, but when Crisp comes back, his playing time will go back down to nearly nothing. So I'm thinking I might do it. I also made an offer of sending someone Buehrle and Giles for Jake Peavy. I think that would be a pretty good trade for me in the long term. I'm trying to include a prospect and get him to include Trot Nixon or Brian Giles so that I have someone to throw out there in RF.