The same Benitez who has 15 IP this year? Yes, the same one. Like I said, you do not know how it would've turned out if he was a Cub. If you say that, then someone can just as easily say "you do not know how it would've turned out if Wood, Prior, and Nomar wouldn't have gotten hurt". Considering that all 3 spent significant time on the DL the previous year, you can assume it's a possibility. As it was a pretty good possibility that Drew was going to get hurt also. That is true, although he wasnt the only OF available.