Hes not a 5th starter, hes a number 3. No he is not. He is 4th at best in this rotation. Zambrano Lilly Marquis Hill Marshall is how the rotation is set. Hes number 3 in the rotation and is paid like a number 3, its not that difficult to see. LOL what a reach. Earlier in this thread you made a big point of how silly it is to harp on a guy's spot in the rotation. Now you're clinging to it as your argument crumbles with each new post showing how wrong you are. Look Marquis was signed to eat innings and provide a league-averageish ERA at the back of the rotation, behind Z, Lilly, Hill at least, and possibly behind another developing youngster (Guzman, Marshall being the top two contenders at the time Marquis was signed). Wanna argue that Marquis is not providing exactly what he was signed to provide? That $7M sure seems like money well spent when you consider what this team suffered through last year using unproven/unready kids at the back end when there was nobody like Marquis around. Is reading really that hard for you? Everybody else was commenting on the spot in the rotation that is the only reason I said anything, but you can keep picking and choosing little bits and pieces to try making your argument. Marquis isnt eating innings either so that argument is bs. Wrong. Yet again. There are 16 teams in the NL -- 5 starters per team, so 90 starters in the NL. Marquis is 30th in the league in innings pitched. So, yes, he is doing a good job of eating innings. Let me ask you an honest question, do you have something personal against Marquis? You've made so many bad arguments in this thread, that I can't help but wonder.