That's the day that I lose a lot of hope, if Neifi is brought back. Can you guys tell me why Neifi would be bad as a true 25th man? Unless you bring back Nomar and know he's likely to have at least one stint on the 15-day disabled list then I could see why you wouldn't want him as a backup. But if that's the case you shouldn't re-sign Nomar. I'm just trying to figure out how many better backup shortstops there are in the majors. Okay, maybe you might want to go with Ronny Cedeno. I just hope everyone realizes this is his first season with good offensive numbers. So if he's your backup and Nomar misses a month or two of the year, is Cedeno going to be an adequate offensive player at shortstop? One year of good numbers (in his rookie year) is better than zero years of good numbers for Neifi. He had one good month this season. Other than that, he's done more harm than good. I'd love to see Nomar back for another year. Don't overpay though. I am not about ready to defend Perez. But I will say this, if you told me on April 1st that he'd have the numbers he has right now in the number of games he's played, I'd take them. Personally, I thought he'd be a .230 hitter with a .250 OBP. But I don't want him to backup if Nomar is re-signed because I already expect Nomar to miss many, many games next year. That's why you have to go with a very capable backup shortstop. Or better yet, not re-sign Nomar. I agree Dal and if Dusty could learn how to use Perez I'd be fine with him as a defensive/injury replacement. Hendry has to get Baker some more quality veteran tools if he wants the Cubs to win.