He doesn't always like to do things that make sense. If you don't trust Cotts here, you really can't ever bring him in (which is becoming increasingly an option). Duncan has over a 300 point split between left-handers and right-handers. You have to try to make use of that split. The whole key is Marmol shouldve started the inning, not a rule 5 kid Would you have taken Marmol out before the 8th then? Id have much less of a problem with Marmol being used against the middle of the order, and then Patton or Guz being used against the lower half in the 8th. What are we saving Marmol for?