A good MLB middle infielder would probably show you his middle finger if you'd ask him to field at silly point 8-) And "hit a little" does injustice to the ability of people like Imran Khan and Wilfred Rhodes, imho On the first point, that's fine. But does silly point really take that much skill? Courage, sure. I guess maybe quick hands. But you are mostly just hoping the ball pops up at you (or sticks in your pocket, as it did for that one guy a few weeks back). As far as all-rounders, that's why I said "usually." But the basic point is that no cricket player will ever be denied a position if they can bowl or bat to an adequate degree. In baseball, there are only a few positions that you can play if you have no defensive skill, and at some positions defense is more important than offense.