First of all, those stats are only batting averages and are incomplete. Let's look at the total productivitiy of each player vs what Alou would bring. Kapler vs LH for 2006 265/367/372 Compared to Alou 349/687/407 That's like the difference between Chase Utley and Mark Grudzielanek. Marrero vs LH 234/315/531 It still pales in comparison to Alou. Furthermore, what sets Alou apart is that if needed, he actually can perform against righties. Kapler vs RH 242/309/323 You wouldn't want him anywhere near a RH pitcher. Marrero vs RH 138/342/241 Once again, horrible. Alou vs RH 286/334/534 That's pretty good right there. So, while it is more money, Alou is a better platoon option and a better replacement regardless of who is on the mound. Alou could be the power hitting bat on the bench regardless of the handedness of the pitcher, while the above are useless unless a LH is on the mound. I'll admit, I don't know if Alou would accpet a part time role, but even if the cost is 5 million, he'd be worth the gamble.