They're in the same class offensively. Defensively, though, Mench is a LF who would be masquerading as a RF. Kearns is a top RF defender. Kearns Before ASB: .224/.306/.394/.700 After ASB: .253/.353/.498/.851 Mench Home: .273/.340/.486/.826 Away: .254/.317/.452/.766 Before ASB: .291/.356/.551/.907 After ASB: .235/.300/.382/.682 Mench is pretty decent in Ameriquest. As bad as Kearns played in the first half of 2005, Mench played worse in the second half. But hey, Kearns got sent down, lol. Add in Kearns's defense and I don't see how the two should be viewed in the same light. Kearns has also had injuries (which do scare me) and a crowded OF to deal with. Could you post Kearns home-away splits too. GABP is also a hitter's heaven.