I respectfully disagree. I don't see how playing the game does anything to make you more likely to be a better manager. It gives you the respect of the players, which is more than any ability to pull together a lineup. It's the same as any job: if you don't have respect for your boss, would you do a good job? The way the baseball world works you have to put in your time in the minors, in the front office, etc. for the major league level. It's an old-school mentality that wouldn't readily accept a manager who has no playing experience. A great coach is a great coach...has nothing to do with his ability as a ball-player. I do see where you are coming from and the Good Old boy system, but esptablish yourself hard, yet respectful the first couple weeks, show that you have knowledge of the game and surround yourself with good people (Atlanta braves for 10 yrs) It is the people around you that can make you look even better and how they are used. It is like the Presidency, bewing a senator and congressmen can only give you a hint of what the job is really like. Nobody knows until they get in there. teh great Pres. surroundd themselve with great people same with MLB managing