It's not as simple as some of you are making it. Yes he is absolutely awful in the outfield. He misplays balls routinely, takes terrible routes, he has amazing trouble ever picking up a ball cleanly off the ground and his arm and where he throws the ball is very inconsistent. Basically all of the bad attributes we've seen from Pagan, Jones, Floyd and Murton exist in Pat. He may not be a terrible downgrade from what we have this year with Floyd, but do we want to be committed to that next year also? He can be extremely inconsistent and disappear for a month or two or more at a time. He hit .215/.378/.408 for a .786 OPS in the first half. He's hit an absurd .404/.526/.697 since the break. Even at age 31, it just scares me that there seems like a decent chance he can revert to '04 or close to '03 numbers. Would I love his bat from the last 3 years in this lineup? Without a doubt. But I'm not so sure I want to commit $14M to him (plus decent prospects) considering his awful defense and the fact that I'm not sure he'll be much of a better overall value than Murton.