We don't need him to be a savior. We need him to play good defense and provide average-above average offense for his position. As far as upgrade, he obviously isn't offensively. But as far as a use of the team's resources he may be. We would be upgrading by a decent amount defensively, paying less than $1M to fill both catcher spots and getting much younger. He won't have a 3-year stretch offensively like Barrett has had, but I think he's capable of putting up an .800 OPS in his best year(s) which combined with his defense and price tag, could make him a great value. It could, if that were realistic, but besides this season, in which he has under 200 ABs, he has never put up an OPS of .800 in the minors. In fact, before this year, his highest OPS was .756 in AA last year. I just hope he can put up a decent .700 OPS, which is more than any of our other catchers are likely to do. His highest OPS was .756 in AA as a 21 year old in 332 at bats. That's a very solid season for a catcher who is young for the league. Last year in 342 AB's he had a .739 OPS as a 23 year old. Again, as a catcher at that age, that's a solid year. He's not going to keep up the pace he has this year, but a .952 OPS in 173 AB's isn't just a few hot weeks. He's maintained steady progress and even his worst year of the last 3.5 wasn't bad considering he was 22 on his first trip to AAA. Also as has been mentioned, catchers tend to develop later on. He has had decent K/BB rates and the power has been coming. Compare his path to guys like Pierzynski, Estrada and you'll see his production and pace hasn't been far off. Heck compare his minor league career to LaRue, Damian Miller, Bengie Molina and Ausmus who either had an .800 OPS or were within 15-20 points a few times. Like I said I don't think he can do it consistently and won't guarantee that it will happen, but I think he is reasonably capable.