Yeah I think a lot of the people who are coveting him don't have a firm grasp of his philosophy. As someone who pays close attention to the Twins, I agree with you. Very concerned about doing the little things the right way, putting the ball in play, situational hitting, values a lot of mediocre veterans, toolsy guys who can play defense, etc. However it is hard to argue with the results vs. their payroll. If he had $100M and could go after a big bat or two to compliment what they've developed in-house, who knows. He gets a lot of the credit for their scouting and development system. Who says just because he has 100 mil to play with he would be any better than he is now. I"m of the belief that big payrools hurt guys like Hendry and Ryan. There is too much emphasis on win now to accept a down year from every once in a while. He woudl be stuck every year trading away his best prospects for aging players. The Yankees are the perfect example of this. Only recently did Cashman convince Steinbrenner to allow him to keep his young guys to help keep the team good for the future. True, good point. It does allow more room for error though and having the flexibility to add just one big bat and another average one at 3B could have put them over the top. Their window of opportunity is starting to close a little bit. You can argue that they would have been better served by trading away some of their arms for a big bat and having a real good chance at winning the WS. As it was due to the payroll constraints, he held on to everyone. Now it looks like Torii will walk this year (no he's not great, but in that lineup he's huge) and Johan will either be traded at the deadline if they're out of it or allowed to walk for a draft pick next November.