Hell no. Barrett is a premier offensive catcher. His defense is not that bad. Yes, he's made a few bad plays you can blow out of proportion this year, but overall he's about average behind the plate, below average in throwing guys out. Seriously look at last years NL catchers fielding stats and tell me what is so atrocious that we should give up Michael's bat. Little bit below average in errors actually, too high in passed balls (not that he's alone there). And he had far less in '05, so it could have been an aberration. Too many stolen bases, but it isn't like he's the only guy teams run on. The Mets somehow had a great year with Lo Duca behind the plate. Yes, Yadier Molina plays steller defense, but he also hits like a little girl. Give me Barrett's bat and his defensive flaws anyday of the week over Yadier. Forget trading him, I want a 3 year deal.